Moonlight & Paw Paw Fishing Lures

Vintage Moonlight Pikaroon, Pollywog, Little Wonder and other collectible lures from the Moonlight Bait Company and Paw Paw Bait Company for sale here.
Auctions Buy It Now All
Enter Zip or Post Code for shipping:
479 itemsPriceShippingTotalTime Left
1941 PAW PAW FLAP JACK 3.5" FISHING LURE-ORANGE SPOTTED-NICE!!! Bid Now »

1941 PAW PAW FLAP JACK 3.5" FISHING LURE-ORANGE SPOTTED-NICE!!!

Bid: $9.99
Ships:
$3.50
$13.49
39 mins
1941 PAW PAW GROOVE HEAD PIKIE WOOD 1.25" FLY ROD FISHING LURE-PIKE SCALE-NICE! Buy Now »

1941 PAW PAW GROOVE HEAD PIKIE WOOD 1.25" FLY ROD FISHING LURE-PIKE SCALE-NICE!

Buy: $15.00 Ships:
$3.50
$18.50
Buy now
39 mins
Moonlight-Bait-Bass-Limited-Edition-2001-No-1-with-Box & Papers, Limited Edition Buy Now »
Free Shipping

Moonlight-Bait-Bass-Limited-Edition-2001-No-1-with-Box & Papers, Limited Edition

Buy: $24.00 Ships:
Free
$24.00
Buy now
1 hr
44 mins
Vintage 3” Wood PAW PAW Fishing Lure  Lot R-261 Buy Now »

Vintage 3” Wood PAW PAW Fishing Lure Lot R-261

Buy: $8.00 Ships:
$2.90
$10.90
Buy now
2 hrs
51 mins
VINTAGE PAW PAW JUNIOR PIKE ? LURE  03/01/16b  WOOD marked lip Buy Now »

VINTAGE PAW PAW JUNIOR PIKE ? LURE 03/01/16b WOOD marked lip

Buy: $16.74 Ships:
$3.95
$20.69
Buy now
4 hrs
16 mins
VINTAGE PAW PAW  PIKE ? LURE  03/01/16b  WOOD marked lip Buy Now »

VINTAGE PAW PAW PIKE ? LURE 03/01/16b WOOD marked lip

Buy: $13.02 Ships:
$3.95
$16.97
Buy now
4 hrs
18 mins
2 UNKNOWN Vintage RIVER RUNT TYPE Lures Paw Paw Tulsa Millsite? Red Green Shore Buy Now »
Free Shipping

2 UNKNOWN Vintage RIVER RUNT TYPE Lures Paw Paw Tulsa Millsite? Red Green Shore

Buy: $11.99 Ships:
Free
$11.99
Buy now
4 hrs
29 mins
Vintage Antique Fishing Lure Comstock Chunk Rare Moonlight Paw Paw Wood Old Bid Now »

Vintage Antique Fishing Lure Comstock Chunk Rare Moonlight Paw Paw Wood Old

Bid: $22.38
Ships:
$3.95
$26.33
4 hrs
30 mins
Vintage fishing lures paw paw Basscaster bass caster 1940 Bid Now » Buy Now »

Vintage fishing lures paw paw Basscaster bass caster 1940

Bid: $25.00
Buy: $50.00
Ships:
$7.15
$32.15
Buy now
4 hrs
40 mins
VINTAGE PAW PAW 9100 ? LURE  03/01/16b  WOOD  BLACK LIP Buy Now »

VINTAGE PAW PAW 9100 ? LURE 03/01/16b WOOD BLACK LIP

Buy: $13.95 Ships:
$3.95
$17.90
Buy now
4 hrs
58 mins
VINTAGE WOODEN PAW PAW LURE!  NICE!!  LQQK! Bid Now »

VINTAGE WOODEN PAW PAW LURE! NICE!! LQQK!

Bid: $6.99
Ships:
$3.75
$10.74
6 hrs
9 mins
VINTAGE WOODEN PAW PAW LURE!  NICE!!  LQQK! Bid Now »

VINTAGE WOODEN PAW PAW LURE! NICE!! LQQK!

Bid: $6.99
Ships:
$3.75
$10.74
6 hrs
14 mins
Large Vintage Paw Paw Wotta Frog Wood Tack Eyes Tough 4” Rare Early Hardware Bid Now »

Large Vintage Paw Paw Wotta Frog Wood Tack Eyes Tough 4” Rare Early Hardware

Bid: $31.00
Ships:
$3.95
$34.95
6 hrs
16 mins
VINTAGE WOODEN PAW PAW LURE!  NICE!!  LQQK! Bid Now »

VINTAGE WOODEN PAW PAW LURE! NICE!! LQQK!

Bid: $6.99
Ships:
$3.75
$10.74
6 hrs
22 mins
VINTAGE WOODEN PAW PAW LURE!  NICE!!  LQQK! Bid Now »

VINTAGE WOODEN PAW PAW LURE! NICE!! LQQK!

Bid: $7.49
Ships:
$3.75
$11.24
6 hrs
24 mins
VINTAGE WOODEN PAW PAW LURE!  NICE!!  LQQK! Bid Now »

VINTAGE WOODEN PAW PAW LURE! NICE!! LQQK!

Bid: $12.59
Ships:
$3.75
$16.34
6 hrs
28 mins
VINTAGE WOODEN PAW PAW SHINER LURE!  NICE!!  LQQK! Bid Now »

VINTAGE WOODEN PAW PAW SHINER LURE! NICE!! LQQK!

Bid: $9.99
Ships:
$3.75
$13.74
6 hrs
32 mins
VINTAGE WOODEN PAW PAW TORPEDO LURE!  NICE!!  LQQK! Bid Now »

VINTAGE WOODEN PAW PAW TORPEDO LURE! NICE!! LQQK!

Bid: $8.99
Ships:
$3.75
$12.74
6 hrs
38 mins
VINTAGE PAW PAW FISHING LURE Bid Now »

VINTAGE PAW PAW FISHING LURE

Bid: $29.99
Ships:
$3.50
$33.49
6 hrs
42 mins
Vintage old wood Jointed minnow, Paw Paw? Gold scale, Glass eyes, unmarked 4.5" Buy Now »

Vintage old wood Jointed minnow, Paw Paw? Gold scale, Glass eyes, unmarked 4.5"

Buy: $10.95 Ships:
$3.00
$13.95
Buy now
7 hrs
20 mins
VINTAGE PAW PAW BAIT CO. FLAP JACK LURE Bid Now »

VINTAGE PAW PAW BAIT CO. FLAP JACK LURE

Bid: $15.00
Ships:
$4.95
$19.95
8 hrs
5 mins
LOT 3 VINTAGE WOOD PAW PAW FISHING LURE BROKEN BACK TAIL TWO PIECE  VERY NICE C8 Buy Now »

LOT 3 VINTAGE WOOD PAW PAW FISHING LURE BROKEN BACK TAIL TWO PIECE VERY NICE C8

Buy: $9.99 Ships:
Based on Zip
$9.99
Plus shipping
Buy now
8 hrs
7 mins
Vintage Lure Flying Ant Made in USA by Arnold Tackle Corp. Paw Paw, MI - NOS NM Buy Now »
Free Shipping

Vintage Lure Flying Ant Made in USA by Arnold Tackle Corp. Paw Paw, MI - NOS NM

Buy: $19.99 Ships:
Free
$19.99
Buy now
8 hrs
33 mins
Vintage Paw Paw Pikie Fishing Lure Bid Now »

Vintage Paw Paw Pikie Fishing Lure

Bid: $6.99
Ships:
$3.95
$10.94
8 hrs
51 mins
 VINTAGE/OLD  FISHING LURES-GRAB BAG OF 11 LURES-PIKIE- HEDDON SONIC-PAW PAW-ETC Bid Now »

VINTAGE/OLD FISHING LURES-GRAB BAG OF 11 LURES-PIKIE- HEDDON SONIC-PAW PAW-ETC

Bid: $15.51
Ships:
$5.00
$20.51
9 hrs
Vintage Paw Paw Jointed Pikie Wood Fishing Lure Bid Now »

Vintage Paw Paw Jointed Pikie Wood Fishing Lure

Bid: $9.99
Ships:
$3.95
$13.94
9 hrs
14 mins
NFLCC 1999 Lure Patch Paw Paw Bid Now »

NFLCC 1999 Lure Patch Paw Paw

Bid: $9.00
Ships:
$1.00
$10.00
9 hrs
27 mins
Vintage Paw Paw Pikie Minnow Lure Series 1600 (4-1/4") wood bait unknown color Buy Now »

Vintage Paw Paw Pikie Minnow Lure Series 1600 (4-1/4") wood bait unknown color

Buy: $25.00 Ships:
$3.00
$28.00
Buy now
9 hrs
59 mins
Lot of 9 Vintage Flatfish Lures X4 T4 U20 Paw Paw Buy Now »

Lot of 9 Vintage Flatfish Lures X4 T4 U20 Paw Paw

Buy: $19.95 Ships:
$4.95
$24.90
Buy now
10 hrs
26 mins
Vintage Paw Paw Fishing lure, Wooden Lure, LOOK Buy Now »

Vintage Paw Paw Fishing lure, Wooden Lure, LOOK

Buy: $5.50 Ships:
$3.00
$8.50
Buy now
11 hrs
44 mins
ODD Pawpaw Minnow In Wattafrog color pattern Bid Now »

ODD Pawpaw Minnow In Wattafrog color pattern

Bid: $9.99
Ships:
$5.00
$14.99
11 hrs
58 mins
OLD VINTAGE POSIBLE PAW PAW ? SHURE STRIKE ? South Bend ? WOOD FISHING LURE Bid Now »

OLD VINTAGE POSIBLE PAW PAW ? SHURE STRIKE ? South Bend ? WOOD FISHING LURE

Bid: $19.99
Ships:
Based on Zip
$19.99
Plus shipping
12 hrs
2 mins
ODD Color South Bend Bass Oreno Heavy Glow red pawpaw Bid Now »

ODD Color South Bend Bass Oreno Heavy Glow red pawpaw

Bid: $9.99
Ships:
$5.00
$14.99
12 hrs
3 mins
Group Lot DD of Vintage Doll Paw Paw Eger Etc Lures Bid Now »

Group Lot DD of Vintage Doll Paw Paw Eger Etc Lures

Bid: $10.01
Ships:
$6.00
$16.01
12 hrs
33 mins
Group Lot U of Vintage Heddon Paw Paw Lures Etc Bid Now »

Group Lot U of Vintage Heddon Paw Paw Lures Etc

Bid: $1.51
Ships:
$6.00
$7.51
12 hrs
42 mins
Group Lot R of Vintage Poes Heddon South Bend Paw Paw Etc Lures Bid Now »

Group Lot R of Vintage Poes Heddon South Bend Paw Paw Etc Lures

Bid: $18.50
Ships:
$6.00
$24.50
12 hrs
45 mins
Tough Creek Chub Shur Strike Paw Paw Mouse Lure Grey 1940 Bid Now »

Tough Creek Chub Shur Strike Paw Paw Mouse Lure Grey 1940

Bid: $3.81
Ships:
$4.99
$8.80
12 hrs
45 mins
VINTAGE PAW PAW WOTTA FROGS (PAIR), WOOD Bid Now »

VINTAGE PAW PAW WOTTA FROGS (PAIR), WOOD

Bid: $41.50
Ships:
$4.50
$46.00
12 hrs
47 mins
Lot Of 43 Antique Fishing Lures HEDDON L&S PAW PAW SHAKESPARE MILLSITE DUNKS Bid Now »
Free Shipping

Lot Of 43 Antique Fishing Lures HEDDON L&S PAW PAW SHAKESPARE MILLSITE DUNKS

Bid: $192.61
Ships:
Free
$192.61
12 hrs
50 mins
Hard To Find Paw Paw Cousin Joe Lure Orange Frog Flash 1940s Bid Now »

Hard To Find Paw Paw Cousin Joe Lure Orange Frog Flash 1940s

Bid: $7.00
Ships:
$4.99
$11.99
13 hrs
Tough Paw Paw #3300 Underwater Minnow Lure Green W Gold Dots 1930s Bid Now »

Tough Paw Paw #3300 Underwater Minnow Lure Green W Gold Dots 1930s

Bid: $32.00
Ships:
$4.99
$36.99
13 hrs
3 mins
Paw Paw Wotta Frog Lure Small Model Bid Now »

Paw Paw Wotta Frog Lure Small Model

Bid: $34.00
Ships:
$6.00
$40.00
13 hrs
19 mins
NEW! >> VINTAGE PAW PAW BAIT CO. "WOTTA FROG" WOOD LURE - NEW in BOX! - L@@K! Bid Now »

NEW! >> VINTAGE PAW PAW BAIT CO. "WOTTA FROG" WOOD LURE - NEW in BOX! - L@@K!

Bid: $64.00
Ships:
$3.50
$67.50
13 hrs
25 mins
Paw Paw Made by Shakespeare Aristocrat Torpedo Surface Rig Frog Spot Bid Now »

Paw Paw Made by Shakespeare Aristocrat Torpedo Surface Rig Frog Spot

Bid: $9.99
Ships:
$6.00
$15.99
13 hrs
30 mins
Paw Paw by Shakespeare Aristocrat Torpedo Surface Rig Bid Now »

Paw Paw by Shakespeare Aristocrat Torpedo Surface Rig

Bid: $9.99
Ships:
$6.00
$15.99
13 hrs
46 mins
Musky Moonlight Little Wonder Bid Now »

Musky Moonlight Little Wonder

Bid: $125.00
Ships:
$6.75
$131.75
14 hrs
24 mins
Vintage Paw Paw No. 60 Hair Mouse Fishing Lure Bid Now »

Vintage Paw Paw No. 60 Hair Mouse Fishing Lure

Bid: $15.50
Ships:
Based on Zip
$15.50
Plus shipping
14 hrs
30 mins
Vintage Paw Paw Fishing Lure - 3&1/2" - Has The Hard To Find Black Lip - Look! Bid Now »

Vintage Paw Paw Fishing Lure - 3&1/2" - Has The Hard To Find Black Lip - Look!

Bid: $4.99
Ships:
$4.00
$8.99
14 hrs
34 mins
3 Vintage Paw Paw Flap Jack fishing lures W/Boxes  Flatfish flat fish Bid Now »

3 Vintage Paw Paw Flap Jack fishing lures W/Boxes Flatfish flat fish

Bid: $12.99
Ships:
$3.50
$16.49
14 hrs
46 mins
Vintage Wooden Paw Paw Pike Fishing Lure Bid Now »

Vintage Wooden Paw Paw Pike Fishing Lure

Bid: $9.99
Ships:
Based on Zip
$9.99
Plus shipping
14 hrs
53 mins


 Search eBay 
Search For In Category Min.
Price
Max.
Price
# Items
Per Page

 

You are here: Home » Moonlight & Paw Paw Lures