Moonlight & Paw Paw Fishing Lures

Vintage Moonlight Pikaroon, Pollywog, Little Wonder and other collectible lures from the Moonlight Bait Company and Paw Paw Bait Company for sale here.
Auctions Buy It Now All
Enter Zip or Post Code for shipping:
407 itemsPriceShippingTotalTime Left
1930 PAW PAW WOOD PIKIE MINNOW 4.25" FISHING LURE-PIKE SCALE-TACK EYES-NICE!!! Buy Now »

1930 PAW PAW WOOD PIKIE MINNOW 4.25" FISHING LURE-PIKE SCALE-TACK EYES-NICE!!!

Buy: $20.00 Ships:
$3.50
$23.50
Buy now
3 hrs
44 mins
Vintage PAW PAW FLUTED PIKIE WOOD 4.5" JOINTED FISHING LURE-RED & WHITE!!! Bid Now »

Vintage PAW PAW FLUTED PIKIE WOOD 4.5" JOINTED FISHING LURE-RED & WHITE!!!

Bid: $7.99
Ships:
$3.50
$11.49
4 hrs
VINTAGE PAW PAW POPPER FISHING LURE tegrnbrn Buy Now »

VINTAGE PAW PAW POPPER FISHING LURE tegrnbrn

Buy: $14.24 Ships:
$3.90
$18.14
Buy now
4 hrs
22 mins
VINTAGE PAW PAW MIDGET SPINNING TORPEDO FISHING LURE Buy Now »

VINTAGE PAW PAW MIDGET SPINNING TORPEDO FISHING LURE

Buy: $21.36 Ships:
$3.50
$24.86
Buy now
4 hrs
22 mins
VINTAGE PAW PAW MIDGET SPINNER FISHING LURE blkfltr Buy Now »

VINTAGE PAW PAW MIDGET SPINNER FISHING LURE blkfltr

Buy: $21.36 Ships:
$3.90
$25.26
Buy now
4 hrs
26 mins
VINTAGE PAW PAW POPPER FISHING LURE gray Buy Now »

VINTAGE PAW PAW POPPER FISHING LURE gray

Buy: $26.70 Ships:
$3.50
$30.20
Buy now
4 hrs
29 mins
1941 PAW PAW FLAP JACK 3.5" FISHING LURE-PIKE SCALE FLASH-NICE!!! Bid Now »

1941 PAW PAW FLAP JACK 3.5" FISHING LURE-PIKE SCALE FLASH-NICE!!!

Bid: $9.99
Ships:
$3.50
$13.49
4 hrs
34 mins
1935 PAW PAW WOOD PLUNKER 3" FISHING LURE-RAINBOW COLORS-BOX!!! Buy Now »

1935 PAW PAW WOOD PLUNKER 3" FISHING LURE-RAINBOW COLORS-BOX!!!

Buy: $25.00 Ships:
$3.50
$28.50
Buy now
4 hrs
34 mins
1941 PAW PAW GROOVE HEAD PIKIE WOOD 1.25" FLY ROD FISHING LURE-PIKE SCALE-NICE! Buy Now »

1941 PAW PAW GROOVE HEAD PIKIE WOOD 1.25" FLY ROD FISHING LURE-PIKE SCALE-NICE!

Buy: $15.00 Ships:
$3.50
$18.50
Buy now
4 hrs
40 mins
Vintage PAW PAW RIVER RUNT WOOD 2.5" FISHING LURE-ARMY GREEN PERCH SCALE-NICE!!! Bid Now »

Vintage PAW PAW RIVER RUNT WOOD 2.5" FISHING LURE-ARMY GREEN PERCH SCALE-NICE!!!

Bid: $7.99
Ships:
$3.50
$11.49
4 hrs
47 mins
Vintage PAW PAW RIVER RUNT WOOD 2.5" FISHING LURE-ARMY GREEN & WHITE SCALE!!! Bid Now »

Vintage PAW PAW RIVER RUNT WOOD 2.5" FISHING LURE-ARMY GREEN & WHITE SCALE!!!

Bid: $7.99
Ships:
$3.50
$11.49
4 hrs
47 mins
Vintage PAW PAW RIVER RUNT WOOD 2.5" FISHING LURE-SILVER FLASH-GLASS EYES-NICE!! Bid Now »

Vintage PAW PAW RIVER RUNT WOOD 2.5" FISHING LURE-SILVER FLASH-GLASS EYES-NICE!!

Bid: $9.99
Ships:
$3.50
$13.49
4 hrs
47 mins
Vintage Wooden Paw-Paw Lure Bid Now »

Vintage Wooden Paw-Paw Lure

Bid: $3.99
Ships:
$3.25
$7.24
6 hrs
47 mins
Scarce Vintage Paw Paw Small Fly Rod Wotta Frog Lure Bid Now »

Scarce Vintage Paw Paw Small Fly Rod Wotta Frog Lure

Antique Fishing lure No Reserve! Worth a L@ @K!
Bid: $21.01
Ships:
Based on Zip
$21.01
Plus shipping
7 hrs
30 mins
Vintage Fishing Lure Box, Paw Paw #3632 for Flap Jack, Clear Slide Top Buy Now »

Vintage Fishing Lure Box, Paw Paw #3632 for Flap Jack, Clear Slide Top

Buy: $9.99 Ships:
$3.50
$13.49
Buy now
9 hrs
37 mins
Paw Paw Nature Mouse - Grey Buy Now »

Paw Paw Nature Mouse - Grey

Buy: $24.99 Ships:
Based on Zip
$24.99
Plus shipping
Buy now
10 hrs
58 mins
PAW PAW 6100 Series WOODEN FISHING LURE 2-5/8" Size White Red Head Finish Buy Now »
Free Shipping

PAW PAW 6100 Series WOODEN FISHING LURE 2-5/8" Size White Red Head Finish

Buy: $14.99 Ships:
Free
$14.99
Buy now
11 hrs
20 mins
Vtg PAW PAW 812 River ROVER Go Getter WOODEN FISHING LURE Silver Flitter Flash Buy Now »
Free Shipping

Vtg PAW PAW 812 River ROVER Go Getter WOODEN FISHING LURE Silver Flitter Flash

Buy: $14.99 Ships:
Free
$14.99
Buy now
11 hrs
20 mins
PAW PAW Junior JR Pike Minnow WOODEN FISHING LURE White Red Head Finish Buy Now »
Free Shipping

PAW PAW Junior JR Pike Minnow WOODEN FISHING LURE White Red Head Finish

Buy: $14.99 Ships:
Free
$14.99
Buy now
11 hrs
24 mins
PAW PAW 2201 Popper WOODEN FISHING Bass LURE Yellow Perch Finish TOP WATER Bait Buy Now »
Free Shipping

PAW PAW 2201 Popper WOODEN FISHING Bass LURE Yellow Perch Finish TOP WATER Bait

Buy: $14.99 Ships:
Free
$14.99
Buy now
11 hrs
24 mins
PAW PAW 2203 Popper WOODEN FISHING Bass LURE Green Gold Scale Finish TOP WATER Buy Now »
Free Shipping

PAW PAW 2203 Popper WOODEN FISHING Bass LURE Green Gold Scale Finish TOP WATER

Buy: $14.99 Ships:
Free
$14.99
Buy now
11 hrs
24 mins
PAW PAW Baby Jointed Pike WOODEN FISHING LURE Gold Scale Brown Back Buy Now »
Free Shipping

PAW PAW Baby Jointed Pike WOODEN FISHING LURE Gold Scale Brown Back

Buy: $16.88 Ships:
Free
$16.88
Buy now
11 hrs
24 mins
VINTAGE<>PAW PAW  "WOUNDED MINNOW" TYPE WOOD LURE<> Bid Now »

VINTAGE<>PAW PAW "WOUNDED MINNOW" TYPE WOOD LURE<>

Bid: $4.99
Ships:
$4.25
$9.24
11 hrs
46 mins
VINTAGE<>PAW PAW  "ARISTOCRAT TORPEDO" #2400 WOOD LURE<> Bid Now »

VINTAGE<>PAW PAW "ARISTOCRAT TORPEDO" #2400 WOOD LURE<>

Bid: $4.25
Ships:
$4.25
$8.50
12 hrs
10 mins
VINTAGE<>PAW PAW  "PIKE" #1600 WOOD LURE<> Bid Now »

VINTAGE<>PAW PAW "PIKE" #1600 WOOD LURE<>

Bid: $6.50
Ships:
$4.25
$10.75
12 hrs
34 mins
Paw Paw 5" metal spoon Bid Now »

Paw Paw 5" metal spoon

Bid: $9.99
Ships:
$5.50
$15.49
14 hrs
4 mins
Paw Paw Pikie Bid Now »

Paw Paw Pikie

Bid: $9.99
Ships:
$5.50
$15.49
14 hrs
4 mins
Paw Paw Wooden Fishing Lure w/Reflective Glitter Bits Added to the Paint No Res. Bid Now »

Paw Paw Wooden Fishing Lure w/Reflective Glitter Bits Added to the Paint No Res.

Bid: $9.99
Ships:
$3.50
$13.49
14 hrs
35 mins
Seagrams 7 Antique Fishing Lure - Paw Paw Bait Co. Michigan Whiskey Liquor Bid Now »

Seagrams 7 Antique Fishing Lure - Paw Paw Bait Co. Michigan Whiskey Liquor

Bid: $12.99
Ships:
$4.00
$16.99
14 hrs
37 mins
PAW PAW PIKE MINNOW LURE WITH RARE PICTURE BOX-4.5 INCH Bid Now »

PAW PAW PIKE MINNOW LURE WITH RARE PICTURE BOX-4.5 INCH

Bid: $110.00
Ships:
Based on Zip
$110.00
Plus shipping
15 hrs
20 mins
VINTAGE WOOD PAW PAW SILVER FLICK SCALE LURE NEW IN ORIGINAL SEALED PLASTIC Bid Now »

VINTAGE WOOD PAW PAW SILVER FLICK SCALE LURE NEW IN ORIGINAL SEALED PLASTIC

Bid: $5.99
Ships:
$3.00
$8.99
15 hrs
30 mins
Unknown Torpedo Lure Paw Paw or Florida Made Bid Now »

Unknown Torpedo Lure Paw Paw or Florida Made

Bid: $5.50
Ships:
$6.00
$11.50
15 hrs
31 mins
VINTAGE WOOD PAW PAW JOINTED LURE NEW IN ORIGINAL SEALED PLASTIC Bid Now »

VINTAGE WOOD PAW PAW JOINTED LURE NEW IN ORIGINAL SEALED PLASTIC

Bid: $7.70
Ships:
$3.00
$10.70
15 hrs
32 mins
NICE VINTAGE PAW PAW WOODEN FISHING LURE Bid Now »

NICE VINTAGE PAW PAW WOODEN FISHING LURE

Bid: $35.99
Ships:
Based on Zip
$35.99
Plus shipping
15 hrs
35 mins
Vintage old wood fishing lure Paw Paw Jointed Deep Diver Piky-Getum Pike Scale Bid Now »

Vintage old wood fishing lure Paw Paw Jointed Deep Diver Piky-Getum Pike Scale

Bid: $9.99
Ships:
$6.00
$15.99
15 hrs
49 mins
Vintage wood fishing lure Paw Paw Jointed Deep Diver Piky-Getum Silver Flitters Bid Now »

Vintage wood fishing lure Paw Paw Jointed Deep Diver Piky-Getum Silver Flitters

Bid: $9.99
Ships:
$6.00
$15.99
15 hrs
51 mins
Vintage Red White Straight Moonlight Pikaroon Lure GE Old Paw Paw MI Buy Now »

Vintage Red White Straight Moonlight Pikaroon Lure GE Old Paw Paw MI

Buy: $84.99 Ships:
$4.00
$88.99
Buy now
16 hrs
15 mins
PAW PAW W0UNDED MINNOW 2500 SHAD EXL Bid Now »

PAW PAW W0UNDED MINNOW 2500 SHAD EXL

Bid: $12.99
Ships:
$4.00
$16.99
16 hrs
19 mins
3 used vintage wooden lures. 2 Heddon & 1 Paw Paw made in the USA Bid Now »

3 used vintage wooden lures. 2 Heddon & 1 Paw Paw made in the USA

Bid: $29.99
Ships:
$3.50
$33.49
16 hrs
40 mins
VINTAGE PAW PAW JUNIOR WOBBLER WOOD FISHING LURE - Buy Now »

VINTAGE PAW PAW JUNIOR WOBBLER WOOD FISHING LURE -

Buy: $9.99 Ships:
$2.90
$12.89
Buy now
17 hrs
5 mins
Paw Paw Cousin Joe Lure Uncataloged Bid Now »

Paw Paw Cousin Joe Lure Uncataloged

Bid: $6.05
Ships:
$6.00
$12.05
17 hrs
9 mins
Paw Paw Pike Caster Lure 6400-S Natural Pike Bid Now »

Paw Paw Pike Caster Lure 6400-S Natural Pike

Bid: $26.00
Ships:
$6.00
$32.00
17 hrs
10 mins
Paw Paw Scoop Nose Diver Lure Uncatalogued Bid Now »

Paw Paw Scoop Nose Diver Lure Uncatalogued

Bid: $3.25
Ships:
$6.00
$9.25
17 hrs
11 mins
Paw Paw Transparent Shore Minnow Series 200 Bid Now »

Paw Paw Transparent Shore Minnow Series 200

Bid: $5.50
Ships:
$6.00
$11.50
17 hrs
12 mins
Paw Paw Mouse Lure Bid Now »

Paw Paw Mouse Lure

Bid: $4.25
Ships:
$6.00
$10.25
17 hrs
13 mins
Beautiful Vintage PAW PAW 3 3/4" Pikie Minnow in Rainbow Bid Now »

Beautiful Vintage PAW PAW 3 3/4" Pikie Minnow in Rainbow

Bid: $9.99
Ships:
Based on Zip
$9.99
Plus shipping
17 hrs
18 mins
Vintage J.C. Higgins 4" PawPaw Minnow Fishing Lure Bid Now »

Vintage J.C. Higgins 4" PawPaw Minnow Fishing Lure

Bid: $9.99
Ships:
Based on Zip
$9.99
Plus shipping
17 hrs
18 mins
Vintage Paw Paw #72 Jr. Wotta Frog Lure In Rare Correct Box - Nice Combo Buy Now »

Vintage Paw Paw #72 Jr. Wotta Frog Lure In Rare Correct Box - Nice Combo

Buy: $94.95 Ships:
Free
$94.95
Buy now
17 hrs
23 mins
vintage paw paw go getter fishing lure Bid Now »

vintage paw paw go getter fishing lure

Bid: $9.95
Ships:
$2.95
$12.90
17 hrs
57 mins
Vintage Moonlight Bait No.1 Collectors Edition 2001 B.A.S.S. In box w paper. Bid Now »

Vintage Moonlight Bait No.1 Collectors Edition 2001 B.A.S.S. In box w paper.

Bid: $2.00
Ships:
$5.90
$7.90
18 hrs
31 mins


 Search eBay 
Search For In Category Min.
Price
Max.
Price
# Items
Per Page

 

You are here: Home » Moonlight & Paw Paw Lures