Moonlight & Paw Paw Fishing Lures

Vintage Moonlight Pikaroon, Pollywog, Little Wonder and other collectible lures from the Moonlight Bait Company and Paw Paw Bait Company for sale here.
Auctions Buy It Now All
Enter Zip or Post Code for shipping:
487 itemsPriceShippingTotalTime Left
Vintage Paw Paw? fishing lure (lot#11232) Bid Now »

Vintage Paw Paw? fishing lure (lot#11232)

Bid: $19.95
Ships:
$3.50
$23.45
12 mins
VINTAGE J.C. HIGGINS PAW-PAW JOINTED WOODEN FISHING LURE 3 3/4"! Buy Now »

VINTAGE J.C. HIGGINS PAW-PAW JOINTED WOODEN FISHING LURE 3 3/4"!

Buy: $6.95 Ships:
Based on Zip
$6.95
Plus shipping
Buy now
27 mins
Antique Fishing Lure Lot 5H Minnow Rotary Baits Paw Paw heddon pflueger folk old Buy Now »

Antique Fishing Lure Lot 5H Minnow Rotary Baits Paw Paw heddon pflueger folk old

Buy: $1,899.00 Ships:
$9.99
$1,908.99
Buy now
1 hr
41 mins
⭐️ Vintage Fishing Lures 12 Heddon GAMBY PAW PAW WOB RITE SPINFIN HEP DUPER TRIX Buy Now »
Free Shipping

⭐️ Vintage Fishing Lures 12 Heddon GAMBY PAW PAW WOB RITE SPINFIN HEP DUPER TRIX

Buy: $39.99 Ships:
Free
$39.99
Buy now
12 hrs
50 mins
PAW PAW JOINTED  WOOD LURE  02/27/17MW  Buy Now »

PAW PAW JOINTED WOOD LURE 02/27/17MW

Buy: $8.95 Ships:
$3.95
$12.90
Buy now
15 hrs
4 mins
Vintage old wood fishing lure Moonlight /PawPaw Bass Seeker Jr. Glass eyes Bid Now »

Vintage old wood fishing lure Moonlight /PawPaw Bass Seeker Jr. Glass eyes

Bid: $2.75
Ships:
Based on Zip
$2.75
Plus shipping
15 hrs
7 mins
LOT OF (2) VINTAGE MOONLIGHT/PAW-PAW LITTLE JIGGER AND JIG-A-LURE 1942 and 1946 Bid Now »

LOT OF (2) VINTAGE MOONLIGHT/PAW-PAW LITTLE JIGGER AND JIG-A-LURE 1942 and 1946

Bid: $2.24
Ships:
Based on Zip
$2.24
Plus shipping
15 hrs
34 mins
Antique Wooden Jointed Paw Paw Fishing Lure Paint Cracks Bid Now »

Antique Wooden Jointed Paw Paw Fishing Lure Paint Cracks

Bid: $19.99
Ships:
Free
$19.99
18 hrs
8 mins
Paw Paw Old Wounded Minnow Vintage antique fishing lures Tough Color lure Bid Now »

Paw Paw Old Wounded Minnow Vintage antique fishing lures Tough Color lure

Bid: $41.00
Ships:
$3.75
$44.75
21 hrs
48 mins
small Paw Paw Wotta Frog old wood fishing lure Bid Now »

small Paw Paw Wotta Frog old wood fishing lure

Bid: $35.00
Ships:
$5.85
$40.85
22 hrs
20 mins
Pawpaw Moonlight bait co. Little Wonder Buy Now »

Pawpaw Moonlight bait co. Little Wonder

Buy: $300.00 Ships:
Based on Zip
$300.00
Plus shipping
Buy now
22 hrs
29 mins
VINTAGE PAW PAW WOTTA FROG FISHING LURE WITH GREEN EYES Buy Now »

VINTAGE PAW PAW WOTTA FROG FISHING LURE WITH GREEN EYES

Buy: $64.99 Ships:
$4.00
$68.99
Buy now
22 hrs
45 mins
Vintage Paw Paw Senior #74 Wonta Frog Fishing lure Bid Now »

Vintage Paw Paw Senior #74 Wonta Frog Fishing lure

Bid: $27.00
Ships:
Based on Zip
$27.00
Plus shipping
22 hrs
46 mins
MOONLIGHT LURES Bid Now »
Free Shipping

MOONLIGHT LURES

Bid: $100.00
Ships:
Free
$100.00
22 hrs
56 mins
BASS LURES EUREKA WIGGLER RUSH-TANGO MOONLIGHT BAIT LOT OF 3 Buy Now »

BASS LURES EUREKA WIGGLER RUSH-TANGO MOONLIGHT BAIT LOT OF 3

Buy: $47.65 Ships:
$4.95
$52.60
Buy now
23 hrs
3 mins
 Vintage Paw Paw Pike green with gold dots Fishing lures Bid Now »

Vintage Paw Paw Pike green with gold dots Fishing lures

Bid: $3.61
Ships:
Based on Zip
$3.61
Plus shipping
23 hrs
31 mins
Fly Rod Runtie Fishing Lure Heddon, Paw Paw ? Buy Now »

Fly Rod Runtie Fishing Lure Heddon, Paw Paw ?

Buy: $27.95 Ships:
$3.95
$31.90
Buy now
1 day
17 mins
Paw Paw River Runt PERFECT, Vintage Fishing Lure, vtg bass lure Buy Now »
Free Shipping

Paw Paw River Runt PERFECT, Vintage Fishing Lure, vtg bass lure

Buy: $34.99 Ships:
Free
$34.99
Buy now
1 day
49 mins
Vintage Paw Paw Wobbler  fishing lure (lot#10196) Buy Now »

Vintage Paw Paw Wobbler fishing lure (lot#10196)

Buy: $12.95 Ships:
$3.25
$16.20
Buy now
1 day
3 hrs
3 mins
Vintage Paw Paw? Mouse fishing lure  (lot#9063) Bid Now »

Vintage Paw Paw? Mouse fishing lure (lot#9063)

Bid: $45.00
Ships:
$3.25
$48.25
1 day
3 hrs
50 mins
21 VINTAGE VARIOUS LURES HEDDON,CREEK CHUB,PAW PAW,AND SOME UNMARKED Bid Now »

21 VINTAGE VARIOUS LURES HEDDON,CREEK CHUB,PAW PAW,AND SOME UNMARKED

Bid: $75.00
Ships:
$15.00
$90.00
1 day
12 hrs
18 mins
Old Jointed Lure Fishing Paw-Paw Collectible (11271-B4-MS) Buy Now »

Old Jointed Lure Fishing Paw-Paw Collectible (11271-B4-MS)

Buy: $15.99 Ships:
$3.99
$19.98
Buy now
1 day
17 hrs
3 mins
Super Early VINTAGE PAW PAW FISHING LURE BOX Pat Pending Bid Now »

Super Early VINTAGE PAW PAW FISHING LURE BOX Pat Pending

Bid: $19.99
Ships:
Based on Zip
$19.99
Plus shipping
1 day
18 hrs
18 mins
Vintage Paw Paw Baits Lure Box Only Bid Now »
Free Shipping

Vintage Paw Paw Baits Lure Box Only

Bid: $25.49
Ships:
Free
$25.49
1 day
19 hrs
8 mins
Two Vintage JC Higgins River Runt Style Fishing Lures With Box Paw Paw Made? G03 Buy Now »

Two Vintage JC Higgins River Runt Style Fishing Lures With Box Paw Paw Made? G03

Buy: $19.99 Ships:
$4.50
$24.49
Buy now
1 day
19 hrs
21 mins
Paw Paw Vintage Fishin Lures Pikie And Jointed Pikie With Box CLEAN!!! Bid Now »

Paw Paw Vintage Fishin Lures Pikie And Jointed Pikie With Box CLEAN!!!

Bid: $9.39
Ships:
$5.99
$15.38
1 day
20 hrs
29 mins
Vintage Wood Fishing Lure South Bend Chug Ike Creek Chub  Paw Paw ? Unmarked Bid Now »
Free Shipping

Vintage Wood Fishing Lure South Bend Chug Ike Creek Chub Paw Paw ? Unmarked

Bid: $9.99
Ships:
Free
$9.99
1 day
22 hrs
6 mins
Vintage Wood Fishing  Lure South Bend Chug Ike Creek Chub  Paw Paw ? Unmarked Bid Now »
Free Shipping

Vintage Wood Fishing Lure South Bend Chug Ike Creek Chub Paw Paw ? Unmarked

Bid: $9.99
Ships:
Free
$9.99
1 day
22 hrs
7 mins
Vintage Wooden Fishing Lure - Paw Paw 1300 Series Pumpkin Seed - Red and White Buy Now »

Vintage Wooden Fishing Lure - Paw Paw 1300 Series Pumpkin Seed - Red and White

Buy: $24.74 Ships:
$3.50
$28.24
Buy now
1 day
22 hrs
36 mins
Vintage Wooden Fishing Lure - Paw Paw Wobbler - 3 1/8" Buy Now »

Vintage Wooden Fishing Lure - Paw Paw Wobbler - 3 1/8"

Buy: $7.74 Ships:
$3.50
$11.24
Buy now
1 day
22 hrs
44 mins
JOINTED  PAW PAW  PIKE WOOD LURE  12/01/16  Buy Now »

JOINTED PAW PAW PIKE WOOD LURE 12/01/16

Buy: $16.15 Ships:
$3.95
$20.10
Buy now
1 day
23 hrs
24 mins
JOINTED  PAW PAW  PIKE WOOD LURE  12/01/16  TOUGH COLOR Buy Now »

JOINTED PAW PAW PIKE WOOD LURE 12/01/16 TOUGH COLOR

Buy: $22.45 Ships:
$3.95
$26.40
Buy now
1 day
23 hrs
26 mins
NICE   PAW PAW  SHINER CASTER ?  WOOD LURE  12/01/16  3-5/8" Buy Now »

NICE PAW PAW SHINER CASTER ? WOOD LURE 12/01/16 3-5/8"

Buy: $89.95 Ships:
$3.95
$93.90
Buy now
1 day
23 hrs
44 mins
VINTAGE PAW PAW JOINTED PIKIE MINNOW Bid Now »

VINTAGE PAW PAW JOINTED PIKIE MINNOW

Bid: $1.99
Ships:
Based on Zip
$1.99
Plus shipping
2 days
11 mins
Vintage Wooden Fishing Lure - Paw Paw Pikie Minnow Buy Now »

Vintage Wooden Fishing Lure - Paw Paw Pikie Minnow

Buy: $9.99 Ships:
$3.50
$13.49
Buy now
2 days
53 mins
Vintage Wooden Fishing Lure - Paw Paw Runt - Worm Burn Damage Buy Now »

Vintage Wooden Fishing Lure - Paw Paw Runt - Worm Burn Damage

Buy: $7.99 Ships:
$3.50
$11.49
Buy now
2 days
1 hr
13 mins
Vintage paw paw fishing lures Bid Now »

Vintage paw paw fishing lures

Bid: $1.99
Ships:
Based on Zip
$1.99
Plus shipping
2 days
7 hrs
58 mins
vintage fishing lures paw paw Paul Bunyan’s sinker set Bid Now »

vintage fishing lures paw paw Paul Bunyan’s sinker set

Bid: $10.00
Ships:
Based on Zip
$10.00
Plus shipping
2 days
8 hrs
21 mins
Vintage Paw Paw Aristocrat Torpedo - NICE Bid Now »

Vintage Paw Paw Aristocrat Torpedo - NICE

Bid: $20.00
Ships:
Based on Zip
$20.00
Plus shipping
2 days
9 hrs
13 mins
Vintage Paw Paw River Go-Getter Gold Perch - BEAUTIFUL Bid Now »

Vintage Paw Paw River Go-Getter Gold Perch - BEAUTIFUL

Bid: $35.00
Ships:
Based on Zip
$35.00
Plus shipping
2 days
9 hrs
14 mins
Paw Paw Lure Buy Now »
Free Shipping

Paw Paw Lure

Buy: $15.85 Ships:
Free
$15.85
Buy now
2 days
11 hrs
41 mins
Vintage 3-1/4” Wooden PAW-PAW (Pikie?) Fishing Lure  Lot 3-143 Buy Now »

Vintage 3-1/4” Wooden PAW-PAW (Pikie?) Fishing Lure Lot 3-143

Buy: $15.30 Ships:
$2.95
$18.25
Buy now
2 days
13 hrs
49 mins
Origina Paw Paw Wotta Frog near mint condition. Bid Now »

Origina Paw Paw Wotta Frog near mint condition.

Bid: $35.99
Ships:
Based on Zip
$35.99
Plus shipping
2 days
13 hrs
57 mins
Paw Paw Wotta Frog Vintage Fishing Lure Bid Now »

Paw Paw Wotta Frog Vintage Fishing Lure

Bid: $29.99
Ships:
Based on Zip
$29.99
Plus shipping
2 days
14 hrs
30 mins
Beautiful Original Vintage Paw Paw Hair Mouse in Green Color Buy Now »

Beautiful Original Vintage Paw Paw Hair Mouse in Green Color

Buy: $29.95 Ships:
$5.95
$35.90
Buy now
2 days
16 hrs
13 mins
Paw -Paw Wood Fishing Lure Buy Now »
Free Shipping

Paw -Paw Wood Fishing Lure

Buy: $25.00 Ships:
Free
$25.00
Buy now
2 days
18 hrs
20 mins
Lucky Lures By Paw Paw Bait Co. Lot Of 3 Bid Now »

Lucky Lures By Paw Paw Bait Co. Lot Of 3

Bid: $45.00
Ships:
Based on Zip
$45.00
Plus shipping
2 days
18 hrs
33 mins
BEAUTIFUL Creek chub south bend Paw Paw orange rainbow UNKNOWN Tack eyes Lure Bid Now »

BEAUTIFUL Creek chub south bend Paw Paw orange rainbow UNKNOWN Tack eyes Lure

Bid: $19.99
Ships:
$3.50
$23.49
2 days
20 hrs
24 mins
Vintage moonlight lure ? Lure. wood Bid Now » Buy Now »

Vintage moonlight lure ? Lure. wood

Bid: $5.00
Buy: $50.00
Ships:
$3.00
$8.00
Buy now
2 days
20 hrs
32 mins
Vintage (Paw Paw?) Moonlight Pikaroon Tack Eyes (TPE) Lure. Turned Up Nose. Rare Buy Now »

Vintage (Paw Paw?) Moonlight Pikaroon Tack Eyes (TPE) Lure. Turned Up Nose. Rare

Buy: $85.95 Ships:
Based on Zip
$85.95
Plus shipping
Buy now
2 days
22 hrs
26 mins


 Search eBay 
Search For In Category Min.
Price
Max.
Price
# Items
Per Page

 

You are here: Home » Moonlight & Paw Paw Lures