Moonlight & Paw Paw Fishing Lures

Vintage Moonlight Pikaroon, Pollywog, Little Wonder and other collectible lures from the Moonlight Bait Company and Paw Paw Bait Company for sale here.
Auctions Buy It Now All
Enter Zip or Post Code for shipping:
464 itemsPriceShippingTotalTime Left
Vintage 3.25" Paw Paw Wood Lure Perch Fishing Bid Now »

Vintage 3.25" Paw Paw Wood Lure Perch Fishing

Bid: $3.50
Ships:
$3.50
$7.00
13 mins
Vintage 3.25" Paw Paw Wood Lure Fishing Bid Now »

Vintage 3.25" Paw Paw Wood Lure Fishing

Bid: $4.25
Ships:
$3.50
$7.75
23 mins
PAW PAW BAIT COMPANY "Pack Shovel"  RARE!!!!!!!!!! Bid Now »

PAW PAW BAIT COMPANY "Pack Shovel" RARE!!!!!!!!!!

Bid: $75.00
Ships:
$12.00
$87.00
59 mins
Paw paw? fishing lure & Shur Stirke? fishing lure (lot#10158) Buy Now »

Paw paw? fishing lure & Shur Stirke? fishing lure (lot#10158)

Buy: $11.95 Ships:
$3.50
$15.45
Buy now
1 hr
Vintage Paw Paw Bass Wobbler Fishing Lure Frog Pat. Tackle Box Find Lot #511 Bid Now »

Vintage Paw Paw Bass Wobbler Fishing Lure Frog Pat. Tackle Box Find Lot #511

Bid: $6.99
Ships:
$2.99
$9.98
1 hr
13 mins
Vintage Pawpaw Feather Casting Minnow Buy Now »

Vintage Pawpaw Feather Casting Minnow

Buy: $46.79 Ships:
$4.99
$51.78
Buy now
2 hrs
4 mins
Vintage 3” Wood PAW-PAW Dapper Dan Fishing Lure  Lot 2-274 Bid Now »

Vintage 3” Wood PAW-PAW Dapper Dan Fishing Lure Lot 2-274

Bid: $12.00
Ships:
$2.90
$14.90
2 hrs
5 mins
Vintage 3-1/2” Wood Jointed PAW-PAW J.C. Higgins Fishing Lure  Lot 2-271 Bid Now »

Vintage 3-1/2” Wood Jointed PAW-PAW J.C. Higgins Fishing Lure Lot 2-271

Bid: $14.00
Ships:
$2.90
$16.90
2 hrs
5 mins
Vintage 4-1/2” Wood PAW-PAW Fluted Pikie Minnow Fishing Lure  Lot 2-305 Bid Now »

Vintage 4-1/2” Wood PAW-PAW Fluted Pikie Minnow Fishing Lure Lot 2-305

Bid: $14.00
Ships:
$2.90
$16.90
2 hrs
5 mins
Vintage Pawpaw Great Injured Minnow Buy Now »

Vintage Pawpaw Great Injured Minnow

Buy: $70.19 Ships:
$4.99
$75.18
Buy now
2 hrs
8 mins
Vintage, Wooden, Paw Paw Pike Minnow Fishing Lure, c. 1935, Fine Shape Bid Now »

Vintage, Wooden, Paw Paw Pike Minnow Fishing Lure, c. 1935, Fine Shape

Bid: $14.99
Ships:
$4.00
$18.99
2 hrs
52 mins
PAW PAW CASTER NFLCC VINTAGE TACKLE COLLECTORS PATCH!!! Buy Now »
Free Shipping

PAW PAW CASTER NFLCC VINTAGE TACKLE COLLECTORS PATCH!!!

Buy: $14.75 Ships:
Free
$14.75
Buy now
5 hrs
43 mins
MOONLIGHT PIKAROON NFLCC VINTAGE TACKLE COLLECTORS PATCH!!! Buy Now »
Free Shipping

MOONLIGHT PIKAROON NFLCC VINTAGE TACKLE COLLECTORS PATCH!!!

Buy: $14.75 Ships:
Free
$14.75
Buy now
5 hrs
48 mins
Vintage Paw Paw Wooden Fishing Lure Plug Buy Now »

Vintage Paw Paw Wooden Fishing Lure Plug

Buy: $9.99 Ships:
$3.00
$12.99
Buy now
11 hrs
48 mins
MOONLIGHT LURE Bid Now »
Free Shipping

MOONLIGHT LURE

Bid: $80.00
Ships:
Free
$80.00
12 hrs
3 mins
Paw Paw Jointed Pike Minnow with Tack Eyes Buy Now »

Paw Paw Jointed Pike Minnow with Tack Eyes

Buy: $25.00 Ships:
$5.00
$30.00
Buy now
12 hrs
29 mins
PAW PAW ? OLD WOUNDED  MINNOW WOOD LURE  12/26/16  Buy Now »

PAW PAW ? OLD WOUNDED MINNOW WOOD LURE 12/26/16

Buy: $15.59 Ships:
$3.95
$19.54
Buy now
14 hrs
58 mins
Vintage Pawpaw Co Perch Color wooden lure Buy Now »

Vintage Pawpaw Co Perch Color wooden lure

Buy: $9.00 Ships:
Based on Zip
$9.00
Plus shipping
Buy now
15 hrs
50 mins
Vintage Fishing Lures ~ Lot of 7 ~Wood -Red & White / 1- Paw-Paw & Fred Arbogast Bid Now »

Vintage Fishing Lures ~ Lot of 7 ~ Wood -Red & White / 1- Paw-Paw & Fred Arbogast

Bid: $14.75
Ships:
$6.85
$21.60
17 hrs
25 mins
PAW PAW JIG A LURE #2700 WOOD LURE Buy Now »

PAW PAW JIG A LURE #2700 WOOD LURE

Buy: $8.99 Ships:
$3.50
$12.49
Buy now
17 hrs
26 mins
LOT OF 2 VINTAGE PAW PAW SHAKESPEARE DAPPER DAN MILLSITE RIVER RUNT LURES Buy Now »

LOT OF 2 VINTAGE PAW PAW SHAKESPEARE DAPPER DAN MILLSITE RIVER RUNT LURES

Buy: $14.99 Ships:
$2.95
$17.94
Buy now
17 hrs
33 mins
Vintage Paw Paw Clothe's Pin Bait ( Make 'em Strike ) Bid Now »

Vintage Paw Paw Clothe's Pin Bait ( Make 'em Strike )

Bid: $2.00
Ships:
Based on Zip
$2.00
Plus shipping
18 hrs
32 mins
Vintage Fishing Lure Frog Paw Paw Yellow Vintage Bait Fish Lures Old Bid Now »

Vintage Fishing Lure Frog Paw Paw Yellow Vintage Bait Fish Lures Old

Bid: $15.00
Ships:
$4.00
$19.00
19 hrs
22 mins
Vintage 3-1/2” Wood Jointed PAW-PAW Baby Pikie Fishing Lure  Lot 2-270 Bid Now »

Vintage 3-1/2” Wood Jointed PAW-PAW Baby Pikie Fishing Lure Lot 2-270

Bid: $14.00
Ships:
$2.90
$16.90
20 hrs
57 mins
Vintage 4-1/2” Wood PAW-PAW Injured Minnow Fishing Lure  Lot 2-268 Bid Now »

Vintage 4-1/2” Wood PAW-PAW Injured Minnow Fishing Lure Lot 2-268

Bid: $12.00
Ships:
$2.90
$14.90
20 hrs
57 mins
Vintage Paw Paw Baby Jointed Pikie #2100 Wood Fishing Lure Buy Now »
Free Shipping

Vintage Paw Paw Baby Jointed Pikie #2100 Wood Fishing Lure

Buy: $19.95 Ships:
Free
$19.95
Buy now
23 hrs
13 mins
Vintage Paw Paw River Go-Getter #800 Wood Fishing Lure Rainbow Buy Now »
Free Shipping

Vintage Paw Paw River Go-Getter #800 Wood Fishing Lure Rainbow

Buy: $32.95 Ships:
Free
$32.95
Buy now
23 hrs
13 mins
Vintage Paw Paw Baby Jointed Pikie Wood Fishing Lure Buy Now »
Free Shipping

Vintage Paw Paw Baby Jointed Pikie Wood Fishing Lure

Buy: $18.95 Ships:
Free
$18.95
Buy now
23 hrs
13 mins
VINTAGE J.C.HIGGINS JOINTED PAW-PAW WOOD LURE Bid Now »

VINTAGE J.C.HIGGINS JOINTED PAW-PAW WOOD LURE

Bid: $41.99
Ships:
$3.55
$45.54
23 hrs
15 mins
PAW PAW JIG A LURE WOOD WOOD LURE   09/03/15B   TOUGH COLOR Buy Now »

PAW PAW JIG A LURE WOOD WOOD LURE 09/03/15B TOUGH COLOR

Buy: $32.20 Ships:
$3.95
$36.15
Buy now
23 hrs
35 mins
Vintage Wood Paw Paw Wobbler #4200  Nice Unfished Bid Now »

Vintage Wood Paw Paw Wobbler #4200 Nice Unfished

Bid: $14.99
Ships:
$2.80
$17.79
1 day
9 mins
7 antique lures by Heddon, Burke, Clark, Paw Paw, Bomber and more. Free Shipping Bid Now »
Free Shipping

7 antique lures by Heddon, Burke, Clark, Paw Paw, Bomber and more. Free Shipping

Bid: $29.99
Ships:
Free
$29.99
1 day
14 mins
Vintage Early Wood Paw Paw Pike Jointed #1000  Nice Unfished Bid Now »

Vintage Early Wood Paw Paw Pike Jointed #1000 Nice Unfished

Bid: $14.99
Ships:
$2.80
$17.79
1 day
22 mins
Vintage Early Wood Paw Paw Pike  #1000  Bid Now »

Vintage Early Wood Paw Paw Pike #1000

Bid: $12.99
Ships:
$2.80
$15.79
1 day
26 mins
Vintage Wood Paw Paw Baby Jointed Pike  #2100 Bid Now »

Vintage Wood Paw Paw Baby Jointed Pike #2100

Bid: $12.99
Ships:
$2.80
$15.79
1 day
37 mins
Vintage Fishing Lure  - Lucky Lures (paw paw) Lippy Joe River Runt Style (O6) Buy Now »

Vintage Fishing Lure - Lucky Lures (paw paw) Lippy Joe River Runt Style (O6)

Buy: $12.00 Ships:
$3.00
$15.00
Buy now
1 day
1 hr
8 mins
Vintage Fishing Lure - Paw Paw Flap Jack (P32) Buy Now »

Vintage Fishing Lure - Paw Paw Flap Jack (P32)

Buy: $10.00 Ships:
$3.00
$13.00
Buy now
1 day
1 hr
8 mins
Rare vintage wood fishing lure blank maybe old moonlight bait, browns bait Buy Now »

Rare vintage wood fishing lure blank maybe old moonlight bait, browns bait

Buy: $15.56 Ships:
$3.95
$19.51
Buy now
1 day
1 hr
16 mins
Vintage Paw Paw? Mouse fishing lure  (lot#9063) Bid Now »

Vintage Paw Paw? Mouse fishing lure (lot#9063)

Bid: $45.00
Ships:
$3.25
$48.25
1 day
3 hrs
26 mins
Paw Paw Wood WOBBLER Lure In PEANUT BUTTER?? Buy Now »

Paw Paw Wood WOBBLER Lure In PEANUT BUTTER??

Buy: $10.00 Ships:
$4.50
$14.50
Buy now
1 day
4 hrs
3 mins
VINTAGE PAW PAW CO. WOOD LURE. Bid Now »

VINTAGE PAW PAW CO. WOOD LURE.

Bid: $6.50
Ships:
$3.95
$10.45
1 day
12 hrs
58 mins
2 Vintage wood paw paw lures Buy Now »
Free Shipping

2 Vintage wood paw paw lures

Buy: $20.50 Ships:
Free
$20.50
Buy now
1 day
14 hrs
33 mins
Vintage Paw Paw jointed minnow lure, bait, old plug, collectable fishing antique Buy Now »

Vintage Paw Paw jointed minnow lure, bait, old plug, collectable fishing antique

Buy: $16.49 Ships:
$3.00
$19.49
Buy now
1 day
17 hrs
40 mins
three old wood fishing lures, two with glass eyes Heddon, Paw Paw, Shur Strike Buy Now »
Free Shipping

three old wood fishing lures, two with glass eyes Heddon, Paw Paw, Shur Strike

Buy: $29.00 Ships:
Free
$29.00
Buy now
1 day
18 hrs
52 mins
4 Vintage Fishing Lures Heddon/Paw Paw Bid Now »

4 Vintage Fishing Lures Heddon/Paw Paw

Bid: $10.75
Ships:
$8.00
$18.75
1 day
19 hrs
15 mins
COOL OLD PAW PAW FROG!!!  Bid Now »

COOL OLD PAW PAW FROG!!!

Bid: $14.50
Ships:
$7.75
$22.25
1 day
19 hrs
57 mins
6 old lurers MUDPUPPY mepps, paw paw, creek chub old vintage fishing lure Bid Now »

6 old lurers MUDPUPPY mepps, paw paw, creek chub old vintage fishing lure

National Recovery Act
Bid: $7.50
Ships:
$8.00
$15.50
1 day
20 hrs
42 mins
Vintage Paw Paw Underwater Minnow Fishing Lure Spoon Bait Pike Antique Spinner Bid Now »

Vintage Paw Paw Underwater Minnow Fishing Lure Spoon Bait Pike Antique Spinner

Bid: $9.99
Ships:
$4.80
$14.79
1 day
22 hrs
16 mins
old fishing lures Paw Paw Sure Strike River Runt Rare Color Wood Bait c. 1940s Bid Now »

old fishing lures Paw Paw Sure Strike River Runt Rare Color Wood Bait c. 1940s

Bid: $1.36
Ships:
$4.00
$5.36
1 day
22 hrs
18 mins
Paw paw antique wooden fishing lure Bid Now »
Free Shipping

Paw paw antique wooden fishing lure

Bid: $49.99
Ships:
Free
$49.99
1 day
23 hrs
51 mins


 Search eBay 
Search For In Category Min.
Price
Max.
Price
# Items
Per Page

 

You are here: Home » Moonlight & Paw Paw Lures