Moonlight & Paw Paw Fishing Lures

Vintage Moonlight Pikaroon, Pollywog, Little Wonder and other collectible lures from the Moonlight Bait Company and Paw Paw Bait Company for sale here.
Auctions Buy It Now All
Enter Zip or Post Code for shipping:
522 itemsPriceShippingTotalTime Left
1941 PAW PAW GROOVE HEAD PIKIE WOOD 1.25" FLY ROD FISHING LURE-PIKE SCALE-NICE! Buy Now »

1941 PAW PAW GROOVE HEAD PIKIE WOOD 1.25" FLY ROD FISHING LURE-PIKE SCALE-NICE!

Buy: $10.00 Ships:
$3.50
$13.50
Buy now
1 hr
2 mins
1941 PAW PAW PERCH CASTER WOOD 2.5" FISHING LURE-PIKE SCALE-NICE!!! Buy Now »

1941 PAW PAW PERCH CASTER WOOD 2.5" FISHING LURE-PIKE SCALE-NICE!!!

Buy: $25.00 Ships:
$3.50
$28.50
Buy now
1 hr
34 mins
Vintage Wooden Paw Paw Pike Fishing Lure Bid Now »

Vintage Wooden Paw Paw Pike Fishing Lure

Bid: $5.99
Ships:
Based on Zip
$5.99
Plus shipping
2 hrs
51 mins
Vintage wood Pike Paw Paw Fluted nose Fishing lure Tough color Bid Now » Buy Now »

Vintage wood Pike Paw Paw Fluted nose Fishing lure Tough color

Bid: $29.99
Buy: $59.99
Ships:
Based on Zip
$29.99
Plus shipping
Buy now
3 hrs
36 mins
Vintage Original Paw Paw Fishing Lure in Frog Spot Color Bid Now » Buy Now »

Vintage Original Paw Paw Fishing Lure in Frog Spot Color

Bid: $19.99
Buy: $27.99
Ships:
Based on Zip
$19.99
Plus shipping
Buy now
3 hrs
44 mins
Vintage Paw Paw Spinner 5" Fishing Lure Buy Now »
Free Shipping

Vintage Paw Paw Spinner 5" Fishing Lure

Buy: $12.99 Ships:
Free
$12.99
Buy now
4 hrs
18 mins
Vintage Paw Paw Pike Minnow 3 hook RARE fishing lure 1935 Buy Now »
Free Shipping

Vintage Paw Paw Pike Minnow 3 hook RARE fishing lure 1935

Buy: $75.00 Ships:
Free
$75.00
Buy now
4 hrs
18 mins
Vintage Paw Paw River Go-Getter fishing lure Buy Now »
Free Shipping

Vintage Paw Paw River Go-Getter fishing lure

Buy: $24.99 Ships:
Free
$24.99
Buy now
4 hrs
18 mins
Vintage Paw Paw Wotta Frog Fishing Lure - Old PawPaw Bait Co. Wotta Frog Lure Bid Now »

Vintage Paw Paw Wotta Frog Fishing Lure - Old PawPaw Bait Co. Wotta Frog Lure

Bid: $28.00
Ships:
$3.85
$31.85
5 hrs
18 mins
 4 Vintage Fishing Lures ( Hinckley, F.E. Chester, Moonlight, Pflueger) Bid Now » Buy Now »

4 Vintage Fishing Lures ( Hinckley, F.E. Chester, Moonlight, Pflueger)

Bid: $100.00
Buy: $130.00
Ships:
$7.00
$107.00
Buy now
5 hrs
35 mins
EARLY PAW PAW RIVER GO GETTER LURE  08/24/17B    Buy Now »

EARLY PAW PAW RIVER GO GETTER LURE 08/24/17B

Buy: $23.20 Ships:
$3.95
$27.15
Buy now
5 hrs
42 mins
Paw Paw Injured Minnow Old fishing lure Bid Now »

Paw Paw Injured Minnow Old fishing lure

Bid: $34.00
Ships:
$4.85
$38.85
6 hrs
8 mins
PAW PAW ? SHUR STRIKE ? WOOD  LURE  10/23/17B  GLASS EYE RUNT Buy Now »

PAW PAW ? SHUR STRIKE ? WOOD LURE 10/23/17B GLASS EYE RUNT

Buy: $10.75 Ships:
$4.25
$15.00
Buy now
6 hrs
11 mins
VINTAGE MOONLIGHT BASS SEEKER WOOD LURE1925 Buy Now »

VINTAGE MOONLIGHT BASS SEEKER WOOD LURE1925

Buy: $78.50 Ships:
$3.55
$82.05
Buy now
8 hrs
27 mins
Vintage wooden MEADOW BROOK Paw-Paw River Runt STRAWBERRY SPOT FISHING LURE Bid Now »

Vintage wooden MEADOW BROOK Paw-Paw River Runt STRAWBERRY SPOT FISHING LURE

Bid: $11.50
Ships:
Based on Zip
$11.50
Plus shipping
8 hrs
32 mins
 VINTAGE/OLD FISHING LURES-GRAB BAG OF 3 LURES- P AND K-  PAW PAW BEST OF LUCK Bid Now »

VINTAGE/OLD FISHING LURES-GRAB BAG OF 3 LURES- P AND K- PAW PAW BEST OF LUCK

Bid: $7.00
Ships:
$5.00
$12.00
8 hrs
47 mins
Vintage Lucky Lures Fishing Lure Box ONLY   -# 6306 Heddon Paw Paw Co Michigan Bid Now »

Vintage Lucky Lures Fishing Lure Box ONLY -# 6306 Heddon Paw Paw Co Michigan

Bid: $34.99
Ships:
Based on Zip
$34.99
Plus shipping
8 hrs
52 mins
J. C. Higgins paw paw jointed lure in perch Bid Now »

J. C. Higgins paw paw jointed lure in perch

Bid: $5.00
Ships:
$3.95
$8.95
9 hrs
Vintage 1939 Paw Paw Underwater Minnow Fishing Lure 3300 Series Rare! Bid Now » Buy Now »

Vintage 1939 Paw Paw Underwater Minnow Fishing Lure 3300 Series Rare!

Bid: $34.99
Buy: $54.99
Ships:
Based on Zip
$34.99
Plus shipping
Buy now
9 hrs
2 mins
J. C. Higgins Paw Paw Tyre Pikie Bid Now »

J. C. Higgins Paw Paw Tyre Pikie

Bid: $5.00
Ships:
$3.95
$8.95
9 hrs
6 mins
J. C. Higgins Paw Paw Tyre Pikie Green Scale Bid Now »

J. C. Higgins Paw Paw Tyre Pikie Green Scale

Bid: $5.00
Ships:
$3.95
$8.95
9 hrs
9 mins
J. C. Higgins Paw Paw Tyre Pikie Bid Now »

J. C. Higgins Paw Paw Tyre Pikie

Bid: $5.00
Ships:
$3.95
$8.95
9 hrs
15 mins
Vintage 3” Metal PAW-PAW Seagram’s 7 Novelty Fishing Lure  Lot 9-177 Bid Now »

Vintage 3” Metal PAW-PAW Seagram’s 7 Novelty Fishing Lure Lot 9-177

Bid: $22.00
Ships:
$2.90
$24.90
10 hrs
1 min
Vintage Paw Paw Wooden Red White Plug Fishing Lure W Stamped Lip - Early Heddon? Bid Now »

Vintage Paw Paw Wooden Red White Plug Fishing Lure W Stamped Lip - Early Heddon?

Bid: $9.99
Ships:
Based on Zip
$9.99
Plus shipping
10 hrs
36 mins
Vintage Fishing Lure Paw Paw ? Bid Now » Buy Now »

Vintage Fishing Lure Paw Paw ?

Bid: $4.99
Buy: $9.99
Ships:
$2.85
$7.84
Buy now
11 hrs
41 mins
PAW PAW PIKIE 3 3/4 INCHES BLACK HARDWARE WOODEN VINTAGE FISHING LURE Bid Now »

PAW PAW PIKIE 3 3/4 INCHES BLACK HARDWARE WOODEN VINTAGE FISHING LURE

Bid: $2.99
Ships:
$4.50
$7.49
11 hrs
49 mins
vintage antique Paw Paw Gold Fish fishing lures Bid Now »

vintage antique Paw Paw Gold Fish fishing lures

Bid: $19.99
Ships:
$3.50
$23.49
12 hrs
vintage antique Paw Paw Jointed piky getam fishing lures Bid Now »

vintage antique Paw Paw Jointed piky getam fishing lures

Bid: $8.99
Ships:
$3.50
$12.49
12 hrs
4 mins
Vintage Paw Paw Mouse Fishing Lure Buy Now »
Free Shipping

Vintage Paw Paw Mouse Fishing Lure

Buy: $29.99 Ships:
Free
$29.99
Buy now
12 hrs
16 mins
Vintage old wood fishing lure Moonlight Mouse White Bid Now »

Vintage old wood fishing lure Moonlight Mouse White

Bid: $19.50
Ships:
$6.00
$25.50
12 hrs
45 mins
Vintage Paw Paw Fishing Lure Bid Now »

Vintage Paw Paw Fishing Lure

Bid: $2.50
Ships:
$4.50
$7.00
12 hrs
45 mins
Vintage old wood fishing lure Paw Paw Mouse Grey Bid Now »

Vintage old wood fishing lure Paw Paw Mouse Grey

Bid: $9.99
Ships:
$6.00
$15.99
12 hrs
47 mins
Vintage old wood fishing lure Paw Paw Jointed Baby Pikie Red Head Flitter White Bid Now »

Vintage old wood fishing lure Paw Paw Jointed Baby Pikie Red Head Flitter White

Bid: $9.99
Ships:
$6.00
$15.99
13 hrs
5 mins
PAW PAW NO.600  WEEDLESS WOW WOOD LURE Bid Now »

PAW PAW NO.600 WEEDLESS WOW WOOD LURE

Bid: $87.10
Ships:
$3.50
$90.60
13 hrs
19 mins
PAW PAW WOOD 4" CASTER LURE Bid Now »

PAW PAW WOOD 4" CASTER LURE

Bid: $45.99
Ships:
$3.50
$49.49
13 hrs
21 mins
PAW PAW WOOD MUD MINNOW CASTER LURE IN BOX Bid Now »

PAW PAW WOOD MUD MINNOW CASTER LURE IN BOX

Bid: $46.00
Ships:
$3.50
$49.50
13 hrs
23 mins
VINTAGE Rare Fishing Lure Moonlight ? Bid Now »

VINTAGE Rare Fishing Lure Moonlight ?

Bid: $5.50
Ships:
$3.85
$9.35
13 hrs
49 mins
Paw Paw Aristocrat Shiner Minnow Lure Bid Now »

Paw Paw Aristocrat Shiner Minnow Lure

Bid: $6.51
Ships:
$6.00
$12.51
13 hrs
55 mins
Paw Paw Crippled Minnow Lure Very Nice Tough Color Model 6400 Bid Now »

Paw Paw Crippled Minnow Lure Very Nice Tough Color Model 6400

Bid: $270.00
Ships:
$6.00
$276.00
13 hrs
56 mins
Paw Paw Caster Minnow Lure Pike Tack Eye over 5" in Length Nice Looking Bid Now »

Paw Paw Caster Minnow Lure Pike Tack Eye over 5" in Length Nice Looking

Bid: $132.50
Ships:
$6.00
$138.50
13 hrs
57 mins
Vintage Fishing Lure Paw Paw shur strike Bid Now »

Vintage Fishing Lure Paw Paw shur strike

Bid: $2.76
Ships:
$3.35
$6.11
13 hrs
58 mins
VINTAGE PAW PAW INJURED MINNOW CREEK CHUB ? Bid Now »

VINTAGE PAW PAW INJURED MINNOW CREEK CHUB ?

Bid: $9.99
Ships:
Based on Zip
$9.99
Plus shipping
14 hrs
46 mins
Moonlight Bait (Collector Edition, 2004) Bid Now »

Moonlight Bait (Collector Edition, 2004)

Bid: $9.99
Ships:
$5.50
$15.49
15 hrs
31 mins
Vintage 4 Old Red & White Wooden Fishing Lures Paw Paw Shur-Strike & More Bid Now »

Vintage 4 Old Red & White Wooden Fishing Lures Paw Paw Shur-Strike & More

Bid: $9.99
Ships:
$6.00
$15.99
15 hrs
42 mins
RARE VINTAGE PAW PAW Jointed Pikie Lure - Antique Jointed PawPaw Fishing Lure Bid Now »

RARE VINTAGE PAW PAW Jointed Pikie Lure - Antique Jointed PawPaw Fishing Lure

Bid: $2.50
Ships:
$3.95
$6.45
15 hrs
48 mins
RARE VINTAGE PAW PAW Jointed Pikie Lure - Antique Jointed PawPaw Fishing Lure Bid Now »

RARE VINTAGE PAW PAW Jointed Pikie Lure - Antique Jointed PawPaw Fishing Lure

Bid: $2.50
Ships:
$3.95
$6.45
15 hrs
49 mins
ANTIQUE  MOONLIGHT PAW PAW JOINTED (? JR.)  RARE GROOVED HEAD / GLASS EYES Bid Now »

ANTIQUE MOONLIGHT PAW PAW JOINTED (? JR.) RARE GROOVED HEAD / GLASS EYES

Bid: $10.00
Ships:
$3.50
$13.50
1 day
1 hr
5 mins
Vintage Paw Paw 2407 Floater Fishing Lure "NIB" Bid Now »

Vintage Paw Paw 2407 Floater Fishing Lure "NIB"

Bid: $15.00
Ships:
$4.00
$19.00
1 day
3 hrs
45 mins
Vintage Paw Paw 2492 Sinker Fishing Lure "NIB" Bid Now »

Vintage Paw Paw 2492 Sinker Fishing Lure "NIB"

Bid: $15.00
Ships:
$4.00
$19.00
1 day
3 hrs
54 mins
Vintage Wooden Fishing Lure - Paw Paw Pike Pikie Silver Flash Buy Now »

Vintage Wooden Fishing Lure - Paw Paw Pike Pikie Silver Flash

Buy: $12.99 Ships:
$3.50
$16.49
Buy now
1 day
5 hrs
4 mins


 Search eBay 
Search For In Category Min.
Price
Max.
Price
# Items
Per Page

 

You are here: Home » Moonlight & Paw Paw Lures