Bagley Lures from The Colors of Bagley's

Some people consider Mike Metzler, who runs The Colors of Bagley's, to be one of the "go-to guys" when it comes to Bagley lures. Here are his current listings of vintage Bagley lures for sale.
Auctions Buy It Now All
Enter Zip or Post Code for shipping:
31 itemsPriceShippingTotalTime Left
Bagley 5-BSOB ~ 10 Rated Color on a 5" Bang O Lure ~ Vintage ~ TOUGH! Buy Now »

Bagley 5-BSOB ~ 10 Rated Color on a 5" Bang O Lure ~ Vintage ~ TOUGH!

Buy: $110.00 Ships:
$3.25
$113.25
Buy now
7 days
20 hrs
35 mins
  • Item Condition: NewNew Bagley 5-BSOB ~ 10 Rated Color on a 5" Bang O Lure ~ Vintage ~ TOUGH! for sale
  • Item Location: Birmingham, AL, USA ZIP 352**
  • Shipping Type: Flat Rate
  • Shipping Cost: $3.25
  • Handling Time: 2 business days
  • Returns Accepted
  • Seller: mauddib3qez   Feedback: 2,936 / 100%
  • See other items for sale from mauddib3qez
Bagley DB3-NM Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ New In Package ~ Hard To Find Color! Buy Now »

Bagley DB3-NM Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ New In Package ~ Hard To Find Color!

Buy: $185.00 Ships:
$3.25
$188.25
Buy now
7 days
20 hrs
35 mins
  • Item Condition: New other (see details)
  • Item Location: Birmingham, AL, USA ZIP 352**
  • Shipping Type: Flat Rate
  • Shipping Cost: $3.25
  • Handling Time: 2 business days
  • Returns Accepted
  • Seller: mauddib3qez   Feedback: 2,936 / 100%
  • See other items for sale from mauddib3qez
Bagley BB2-6F9 Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Collectible ~ Hard to Find ~ Balsa B 2 Buy Now »

Bagley BB2-6F9 Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Collectible ~ Hard to Find ~ Balsa B 2

Buy: $125.00 Ships:
$3.60
$128.60
Buy now
21 days
18 hrs
23 mins
  • Item Condition: NewNew Bagley BB2-6F9 Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Collectible ~ Hard to Find ~ Balsa B 2 for sale
  • Item Location: Birmingham, AL, USA ZIP 352**
  • Shipping Type: Flat Rate
  • Shipping Cost: $3.60
  • Handling Time: 2 business days
  • Returns Accepted
  • Seller: mauddib3qez   Feedback: 2,943 / 100%
  • See other items for sale from mauddib3qez
Bagley BB2-BJC Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Balsa B 2 ~ Undocumented Color Buy Now »

Bagley BB2-BJC Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Balsa B 2 ~ Undocumented Color

Buy: $125.00 Ships:
$3.60
$128.60
Buy now
21 days
18 hrs
23 mins
  • Item Condition: NewNew Bagley BB2-BJC Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Balsa B 2 ~ Undocumented Color for sale
  • Item Location: Birmingham, AL, USA ZIP 352**
  • Shipping Type: Flat Rate
  • Shipping Cost: $3.60
  • Handling Time: 2 business days
  • Returns Accepted
  • Seller: mauddib3qez   Feedback: 2,943 / 100%
  • See other items for sale from mauddib3qez
Bagley FC2-LSB Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Collectible ~ Hard to Find ~ Fat Cat Buy Now »

Bagley FC2-LSB Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Collectible ~ Hard to Find ~ Fat Cat

Buy: $90.00 Ships:
$3.60
$93.60
Buy now
21 days
18 hrs
23 mins
  • Item Condition: NewNew Bagley FC2-LSB Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Collectible ~ Hard to Find ~ Fat Cat for sale
  • Item Location: Birmingham, AL, USA ZIP 352**
  • Shipping Type: Flat Rate
  • Shipping Cost: $3.60
  • Handling Time: 2 business days
  • Returns Accepted
  • Seller: mauddib3qez   Feedback: 2,943 / 100%
  • See other items for sale from mauddib3qez
Bagley FC2-804 Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Collectible ~ Fat Cat Buy Now »

Bagley FC2-804 Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Collectible ~ Fat Cat

Buy: $90.00 Ships:
$3.60
$93.60
Buy now
21 days
18 hrs
23 mins
  • Item Condition: New other (see details)
  • Item Location: Birmingham, AL, USA ZIP 352**
  • Shipping Type: Flat Rate
  • Shipping Cost: $3.60
  • Handling Time: 2 business days
  • Returns Accepted
  • Seller: mauddib3qez   Feedback: 2,943 / 100%
  • See other items for sale from mauddib3qez
Bagley MSS-GBM Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Collectible ~ Monster Shad Buy Now »

Bagley MSS-GBM Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Collectible ~ Monster Shad

Buy: $125.00 Ships:
$3.60
$128.60
Buy now
21 days
18 hrs
24 mins
  • Item Condition: NewNew Bagley MSS-GBM Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Collectible ~ Monster Shad for sale
  • Item Location: Birmingham, AL, USA ZIP 352**
  • Shipping Type: Flat Rate
  • Shipping Cost: $3.60
  • Handling Time: 2 business days
  • Returns Accepted
  • Seller: mauddib3qez   Feedback: 2,943 / 100%
  • See other items for sale from mauddib3qez
Bagley FC2-CSY Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Collectible ~ Fat Cat Buy Now »

Bagley FC2-CSY Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Collectible ~ Fat Cat

Buy: $48.00 Ships:
$3.60
$51.60
Buy now
21 days
18 hrs
24 mins
  • Item Condition: New other (see details)
  • Item Location: Birmingham, AL, USA ZIP 352**
  • Shipping Type: Flat Rate
  • Shipping Cost: $3.60
  • Handling Time: 2 business days
  • Returns Accepted
  • Seller: mauddib3qez   Feedback: 2,943 / 100%
  • See other items for sale from mauddib3qez
Bagley BB4-CW Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Collectible ~ Hard to Find ~ Balsa B 4 Buy Now »

Bagley BB4-CW Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Collectible ~ Hard to Find ~ Balsa B 4

Buy: $185.00 Ships:
$3.60
$188.60
Buy now
21 days
18 hrs
24 mins
  • Item Condition: New other (see details)
  • Item Location: Birmingham, AL, USA ZIP 352**
  • Shipping Type: Flat Rate
  • Shipping Cost: $3.60
  • Handling Time: 2 business days
  • Returns Accepted
  • Seller: mauddib3qez   Feedback: 2,943 / 100%
  • See other items for sale from mauddib3qez
Bagley FC2-HB0 Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Collectible ~ Fat Cat Buy Now »

Bagley FC2-HB0 Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Collectible ~ Fat Cat

Buy: $90.00 Ships:
$3.60
$93.60
Buy now
21 days
18 hrs
24 mins
  • Item Condition: Used
  • Item Location: Birmingham, AL, USA ZIP 352**
  • Shipping Type: Flat Rate
  • Shipping Cost: $3.60
  • Handling Time: 2 business days
  • Returns Accepted
  • Seller: mauddib3qez   Feedback: 2,943 / 100%
  • See other items for sale from mauddib3qez
Bagley FC2-118 Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Collectible ~ Fat Cat Buy Now »

Bagley FC2-118 Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Collectible ~ Fat Cat

Buy: $65.00 Ships:
$3.60
$68.60
Buy now
21 days
18 hrs
24 mins
  • Item Condition: New other (see details)
  • Item Location: Birmingham, AL, USA ZIP 352**
  • Shipping Type: Flat Rate
  • Shipping Cost: $3.60
  • Handling Time: 2 business days
  • Returns Accepted
  • Seller: mauddib3qez   Feedback: 2,943 / 100%
  • See other items for sale from mauddib3qez
Bagley BB2-BC Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Collectible ~ Hard to Find ~ Balsa B 2 Buy Now »

Bagley BB2-BC Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Collectible ~ Hard to Find ~ Balsa B 2

Buy: $65.00 Ships:
$3.60
$68.60
Buy now
21 days
18 hrs
24 mins
  • Item Condition: NewNew Bagley BB2-BC Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Collectible ~ Hard to Find ~ Balsa B 2 for sale
  • Item Location: Birmingham, AL, USA ZIP 352**
  • Shipping Type: Flat Rate
  • Shipping Cost: $3.60
  • Handling Time: 2 business days
  • Returns Accepted
  • Seller: mauddib3qez   Feedback: 2,943 / 100%
  • See other items for sale from mauddib3qez
Bagley BB2-F79S Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Collectible ~ Hard to Find ~ Balsa B 2 Buy Now »

Bagley BB2-F79S Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Collectible ~ Hard to Find ~ Balsa B 2

Buy: $250.00 Ships:
$3.25
$253.25
Buy now
27 days
18 hrs
14 mins
  • Item Condition: New other (see details)
  • Item Location: Birmingham, AL, USA ZIP 352**
  • Shipping Type: Flat Rate
  • Shipping Cost: $3.25
  • Handling Time: 2 business days
  • Returns Accepted
  • Seller: mauddib3qez   Feedback: 2,944 / 100%
  • See other items for sale from mauddib3qez
Bagley DKB2-LG9 Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Kill'R B 2 ~ Hard to Find ~ Killer B 2 Buy Now »

Bagley DKB2-LG9 Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Kill'R B 2 ~ Hard to Find ~ Killer B 2

Buy: $90.00 Ships:
$3.25
$93.25
Buy now
27 days
18 hrs
14 mins
  • Item Condition: New other (see details)
  • Item Location: Birmingham, AL, USA ZIP 352**
  • Shipping Type: Flat Rate
  • Shipping Cost: $3.25
  • Handling Time: 2 business days
  • Returns Accepted
  • Seller: mauddib3qez   Feedback: 2,944 / 100%
  • See other items for sale from mauddib3qez
Bagley BB3R-GOS Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Collectible ~ Hard to Find Buy Now »

Bagley BB3R-GOS Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Collectible ~ Hard to Find

Buy: $92.00 Ships:
$3.25
$95.25
Buy now
27 days
18 hrs
14 mins
  • Item Condition: New other (see details)
  • Item Location: Birmingham, AL, USA ZIP 352**
  • Shipping Type: Flat Rate
  • Shipping Cost: $3.25
  • Handling Time: 2 business days
  • Returns Accepted
  • Seller: mauddib3qez   Feedback: 2,944 / 100%
  • See other items for sale from mauddib3qez
Bagley DKB2-69 Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Kill'R B 2 ~ Hard to Find ~ Killer B 2 Buy Now »

Bagley DKB2-69 Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Kill'R B 2 ~ Hard to Find ~ Killer B 2

Buy: $60.00 Ships:
$3.25
$63.25
Buy now
27 days
18 hrs
14 mins
  • Item Condition: New other (see details)
  • Item Location: Birmingham, AL, USA ZIP 352**
  • Shipping Type: Flat Rate
  • Shipping Cost: $3.25
  • Handling Time: 2 business days
  • Returns Accepted
  • Seller: mauddib3qez   Feedback: 2,944 / 100%
  • See other items for sale from mauddib3qez
Bagley SPB2-G0 Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Collectible ~ Hard to Find ~ Pop'N B Buy Now »

Bagley SPB2-G0 Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Collectible ~ Hard to Find ~ Pop'N B

Buy: $70.00 Ships:
$3.25
$73.25
Buy now
27 days
18 hrs
14 mins
  • Item Condition: New other (see details)
  • Item Location: Birmingham, AL, USA ZIP 352**
  • Shipping Type: Flat Rate
  • Shipping Cost: $3.25
  • Handling Time: 2 business days
  • Returns Accepted
  • Seller: mauddib3qez   Feedback: 2,944 / 100%
  • See other items for sale from mauddib3qez
Bagley DB1-CW Fishing Lure * Diving B 1 * Vintage Bait * Diving B 1       Buy Now »

Bagley DB1-CW Fishing Lure * Diving B 1 * Vintage Bait * Diving B 1

Buy: $175.00 Ships:
$3.25
$178.25
Buy now
27 days
18 hrs
14 mins
  • Item Condition: NewNew Bagley DB1-CW Fishing Lure * Diving B 1 * Vintage Bait * Diving B 1        for sale
  • Item Location: Birmingham, AL, USA ZIP 352**
  • Shipping Type: Flat Rate
  • Shipping Cost: $3.25
  • Handling Time: 1 business day
  • Returns Accepted
  • Seller: mauddib3qez   Feedback: 2,944 / 100%
  • See other items for sale from mauddib3qez
Bagley 4DSF2-F79S Fishing Lure * Small Fry Shad * Vintage Bait * Collectible Buy Now »

Bagley 4DSF2-F79S Fishing Lure * Small Fry Shad * Vintage Bait * Collectible

Buy: $28.00 Ships:
$3.25
$31.25
Buy now
27 days
18 hrs
14 mins
  • Item Condition: NewNew Bagley 4DSF2-F79S Fishing Lure * Small Fry Shad * Vintage Bait * Collectible for sale
  • Item Location: Birmingham, AL, USA ZIP 352**
  • Shipping Type: Flat Rate
  • Shipping Cost: $3.25
  • Handling Time: 1 business day
  • Returns Accepted
  • Seller: mauddib3qez   Feedback: 2,944 / 100%
  • See other items for sale from mauddib3qez
Bagley CS3-06BN Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Hard to Find ~ Chatter Shad Buy Now »

Bagley CS3-06BN Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Hard to Find ~ Chatter Shad

Buy: $115.00 Ships:
$3.25
$118.25
Buy now
27 days
18 hrs
14 mins
  • Item Condition: New other (see details)
  • Item Location: Birmingham, AL, USA ZIP 352**
  • Shipping Type: Flat Rate
  • Shipping Cost: $3.25
  • Handling Time: 2 business days
  • Returns Accepted
  • Seller: mauddib3qez   Feedback: 2,944 / 100%
  • See other items for sale from mauddib3qez
Bagley RF2-PGS9 Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Collectible ~ Hard to Find ~ Rat Fink Buy Now »

Bagley RF2-PGS9 Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Collectible ~ Hard to Find ~ Rat Fink

Buy: $260.00 Ships:
$3.25
$263.25
Buy now
27 days
18 hrs
14 mins
  • Item Condition: New other (see details)
  • Item Location: Birmingham, AL, USA ZIP 352**
  • Shipping Type: Flat Rate
  • Shipping Cost: $3.25
  • Handling Time: 2 business days
  • Returns Accepted
  • Seller: mauddib3qez   Feedback: 2,944 / 100%
  • See other items for sale from mauddib3qez
Bagley DB3-PGS9 Fishing Lure * Diving B 3 * Vintage Bait * Collectible Buy Now »

Bagley DB3-PGS9 Fishing Lure * Diving B 3 * Vintage Bait * Collectible

Buy: $75.00 Ships:
$3.25
$78.25
Buy now
27 days
18 hrs
14 mins
  • Item Condition:
  • Item Location: Birmingham, AL, USA ZIP 352**
  • Shipping Type: Flat Rate
  • Shipping Cost: $3.25
  • Handling Time: 1 business day
  • Returns Accepted
  • Seller: mauddib3qez   Feedback: 2,944 / 100%
  • See other items for sale from mauddib3qez
Bagley DKB2-AG9 Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Kill'R B 2 ~ Hard to Find ~ Killer B 2 Buy Now »

Bagley DKB2-AG9 Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Kill'R B 2 ~ Hard to Find ~ Killer B 2

Buy: $90.00 Ships:
$3.25
$93.25
Buy now
27 days
18 hrs
14 mins
  • Item Condition: New other (see details)
  • Item Location: Birmingham, AL, USA ZIP 352**
  • Shipping Type: Flat Rate
  • Shipping Cost: $3.25
  • Handling Time: 2 business days
  • Returns Accepted
  • Seller: mauddib3qez   Feedback: 2,944 / 100%
  • See other items for sale from mauddib3qez
Bagley DB3-TIG Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Collectible ~ Hard to Find Buy Now »

Bagley DB3-TIG Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Collectible ~ Hard to Find

Buy: $175.00 Ships:
$3.25
$178.25
Buy now
27 days
18 hrs
14 mins
  • Item Condition: New other (see details)
  • Item Location: Birmingham, AL, USA ZIP 352**
  • Shipping Type: Flat Rate
  • Shipping Cost: $3.25
  • Handling Time: 2 business days
  • Returns Accepted
  • Seller: mauddib3qez   Feedback: 2,944 / 100%
  • See other items for sale from mauddib3qez
Bagley 4DSF2-H2G Fishing Lure * Small Fry Shad * Vintage Bait * Collectible Buy Now »

Bagley 4DSF2-H2G Fishing Lure * Small Fry Shad * Vintage Bait * Collectible

Buy: $65.00 Ships:
$3.25
$68.25
Buy now
27 days
18 hrs
14 mins
  • Item Condition: NewNew Bagley 4DSF2-H2G Fishing Lure * Small Fry Shad * Vintage Bait * Collectible for sale
  • Item Location: Birmingham, AL, USA ZIP 352**
  • Shipping Type: Flat Rate
  • Shipping Cost: $3.25
  • Handling Time: 1 business day
  • Returns Accepted
  • Seller: mauddib3qez   Feedback: 2,944 / 100%
  • See other items for sale from mauddib3qez
Bagley SL2-FBS Fishing Lure * Shad a Lac * Vintage Bait * Collectible Buy Now »

Bagley SL2-FBS Fishing Lure * Shad a Lac * Vintage Bait * Collectible

Buy: $22.00 Ships:
$3.25
$25.25
Buy now
27 days
18 hrs
14 mins
  • Item Condition: NewNew Bagley SL2-FBS Fishing Lure * Shad a Lac * Vintage Bait * Collectible for sale
  • Item Location: Birmingham, AL, USA ZIP 352**
  • Shipping Type: Flat Rate
  • Shipping Cost: $3.25
  • Handling Time: 1 business day
  • Returns Accepted
  • Seller: mauddib3qez   Feedback: 2,944 / 100%
  • See other items for sale from mauddib3qez
Bagley BB3-94 Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Collectible ~ Hard to Find ~ Balsa B 3 Buy Now »

Bagley BB3-94 Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Collectible ~ Hard to Find ~ Balsa B 3

Buy: $90.00 Ships:
$3.25
$93.25
Buy now
27 days
18 hrs
14 mins
  • Item Condition: New other (see details)
  • Item Location: Birmingham, AL, USA ZIP 352**
  • Shipping Type: Flat Rate
  • Shipping Cost: $3.25
  • Handling Time: 2 business days
  • Returns Accepted
  • Seller: mauddib3qez   Feedback: 2,944 / 100%
  • See other items for sale from mauddib3qez
Bagley 3-H9G Fishing Lure * Bang O Lure * Vintage Bait * Collectible     Buy Now »

Bagley 3-H9G Fishing Lure * Bang O Lure * Vintage Bait * Collectible

Buy: $140.00 Ships:
$3.25
$143.25
Buy now
27 days
18 hrs
14 mins
  • Item Condition:
  • Item Location: Birmingham, AL, USA ZIP 352**
  • Shipping Type: Flat Rate
  • Shipping Cost: $3.25
  • Handling Time: 1 business day
  • Returns Accepted
  • Seller: mauddib3qez   Feedback: 2,944 / 100%
  • See other items for sale from mauddib3qez
Bagley BB3-SH4 Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Collectible ~ Hard to Find ~ Balsa B 3 Buy Now »

Bagley BB3-SH4 Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Collectible ~ Hard to Find ~ Balsa B 3

Buy: $72.00 Ships:
$3.25
$75.25
Buy now
30 days
21 hrs
48 mins
  • Item Condition: New other (see details)
  • Item Location: Birmingham, AL, USA ZIP 352**
  • Shipping Type: Flat Rate
  • Shipping Cost: $3.25
  • Handling Time: 2 business days
  • Returns Accepted
  • Seller: mauddib3qez   Feedback: 2,944 / 100%
  • See other items for sale from mauddib3qez
Bagley BB2-DC9 Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Collectible ~ Hard to Find ~ Balsa B 2 Buy Now »

Bagley BB2-DC9 Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Collectible ~ Hard to Find ~ Balsa B 2

Buy: $68.00 Ships:
$3.25
$71.25
Buy now
30 days
21 hrs
48 mins
  • Item Condition: New other (see details)
  • Item Location: Birmingham, AL, USA ZIP 352**
  • Shipping Type: Flat Rate
  • Shipping Cost: $3.25
  • Handling Time: 2 business days
  • Returns Accepted
  • Seller: mauddib3qez   Feedback: 2,944 / 100%
  • See other items for sale from mauddib3qez
Bagley BB3-DC9 Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Collectible ~ Hard to Find ~ Balsa B 3 Buy Now »

Bagley BB3-DC9 Fishing Lure ~ Vintage ~ Collectible ~ Hard to Find ~ Balsa B 3

Buy: $68.00 Ships:
$3.25
$71.25
Buy now
30 days
21 hrs
48 mins
  • Item Condition: New other (see details)
  • Item Location: Birmingham, AL, USA ZIP 352**
  • Shipping Type: Flat Rate
  • Shipping Cost: $3.25
  • Handling Time: 2 business days
  • Returns Accepted
  • Seller: mauddib3qez   Feedback: 2,944 / 100%
  • See other items for sale from mauddib3qez


 Search eBay 
Search For In Category Min.
Price
Max.
Price
# Items
Per Page

 

You are here: Home » Bagley Lures » The Colors of Bagley's