Moonlight & Paw Paw Fishing Lures

Vintage Moonlight Pikaroon, Pollywog, Little Wonder and other collectible lures from the Moonlight Bait Company and Paw Paw Bait Company for sale here.
Auctions Buy It Now All
Enter Zip or Post Code for shipping:
405 itemsPriceShippingTotalTime Left
Vintage Paw Paw Wood Wooden Fishing Lure Buy Now »

Vintage Paw Paw Wood Wooden Fishing Lure

Buy: $15.99 Ships:
$2.99
$18.98
Buy now
7 hrs
36 mins
VINTAGE Unknown SALT WATER FISHING LURE WHITE RED HEAD COLOR Paw Paw Creek Chub? Buy Now »

VINTAGE Unknown SALT WATER FISHING LURE WHITE RED HEAD COLOR Paw Paw Creek Chub?

Buy: $24.99 Ships:
Based on Zip
$24.99
Plus shipping
Buy now
10 hrs
31 mins
Paw Paw JOINTED PIKE Minnow Wood 3 1/2” Lure in RED & WHITE!!! Buy Now »

Paw Paw JOINTED PIKE Minnow Wood 3 1/2” Lure in RED & WHITE!!!

Buy: $15.00 Ships:
$5.00
$20.00
Buy now
11 hrs
42 mins
Paw Paw RIVER RUNT Type Minnow Wood 2 5/8” Lure in RED & WHITE!!! Buy Now »

Paw Paw RIVER RUNT Type Minnow Wood 2 5/8” Lure in RED & WHITE!!!

Buy: $15.00 Ships:
$5.00
$20.00
Buy now
11 hrs
45 mins
Vintage Wooden Fishing Lure -Paw Paw Jigger with Black Hardware - Perch Scale Buy Now »

Vintage Wooden Fishing Lure -Paw Paw Jigger with Black Hardware - Perch Scale

Buy: $8.99 Ships:
$3.50
$12.49
Buy now
12 hrs
22 mins
VINTAGE PAW-PAW FLUTED LURE Buy Now »

VINTAGE PAW-PAW FLUTED LURE

Buy: $22.75 Ships:
$3.59
$26.34
Buy now
12 hrs
51 mins
VINTAGE PAW-PAW LITTLE JIGGER LURE 1946 Buy Now »

VINTAGE PAW-PAW LITTLE JIGGER LURE 1946

Buy: $12.99 Ships:
$3.59
$16.58
Buy now
12 hrs
51 mins
Antique Climax Tackle Box w/Antique Lures Paw Paw Buy Now »

Antique Climax Tackle Box w/Antique Lures Paw Paw

Buy: $59.99 Ships:
$7.99
$67.98
Buy now
13 hrs
3 mins
Vintage PAW PAW BAIT CO Wobbler Wooden Fishing Lure Cup Hardware Buy Now »

Vintage PAW PAW BAIT CO Wobbler Wooden Fishing Lure Cup Hardware

Buy: $11.00 Ships:
$3.25
$14.25
Buy now
13 hrs
13 mins
Vintage Paw Paw Fishing lure Buy Now »

Vintage Paw Paw Fishing lure

Buy: $2.99 Ships:
Based on Zip
$2.99
Plus shipping
Buy now
14 hrs
38 mins
Lot of 13 New ( unused ) Paw Paw Topwater Wood Fishing Lures w/ Shipping Box Buy Now »

Lot of 13 New ( unused ) Paw Paw Topwater Wood Fishing Lures w/ Shipping Box

Buy: $99.95 Ships:
$14.95
$114.90
Buy now
16 hrs
8 mins
Vintage Lot of 11 Paw Paw Plunker River Runt Pikie Wood Fishing Lures Buy Now »

Vintage Lot of 11 Paw Paw Plunker River Runt Pikie Wood Fishing Lures

Buy: $39.95 Ships:
$9.95
$49.90
Buy now
16 hrs
8 mins
Paw Paw Wood Fishing Lure Model 901 River Series Tack Eyes Marked Lip 2 5/8" Buy Now »

Paw Paw Wood Fishing Lure Model 901 River Series Tack Eyes Marked Lip 2 5/8"

Buy: $9.95 Ships:
$3.95
$13.90
Buy now
16 hrs
15 mins
Vintage LUCKY LURES Paw Paw Torpedo FISHING BAIT Minnow 2-PROP Wood/Wooden #4 Buy Now »

Vintage LUCKY LURES Paw Paw Torpedo FISHING BAIT Minnow 2-PROP Wood/Wooden #4

Buy: $22.50 Ships:
Based on Zip
$22.50
Plus shipping
Buy now
19 hrs
3 mins
Vintage LUCKY LURES Paw Paw Torpedo FISHING BAIT Minnow 2-PROP Wood/Wooden #3 Buy Now »

Vintage LUCKY LURES Paw Paw Torpedo FISHING BAIT Minnow 2-PROP Wood/Wooden #3

Buy: $25.00 Ships:
Based on Zip
$25.00
Plus shipping
Buy now
19 hrs
3 mins
Vintage LUCKY LURES Paw Paw Torpedo FISHING BAIT Minnow 2-PROP Wood/Wooden #2 Buy Now »

Vintage LUCKY LURES Paw Paw Torpedo FISHING BAIT Minnow 2-PROP Wood/Wooden #2

Buy: $27.50 Ships:
Based on Zip
$27.50
Plus shipping
Buy now
19 hrs
3 mins
Vintage LUCKY LURES Paw Paw Torpedo FISHING BAIT Minnow 2-PROP Wood/Wooden #1 Buy Now »

Vintage LUCKY LURES Paw Paw Torpedo FISHING BAIT Minnow 2-PROP Wood/Wooden #1

Buy: $22.50 Ships:
Based on Zip
$22.50
Plus shipping
Buy now
19 hrs
3 mins
VINTAGE PAW PAW BABY PIKE LURE  9/03/14NY  WOOD Buy Now »

VINTAGE PAW PAW BABY PIKE LURE 9/03/14NY WOOD

Buy: $20.00 Ships:
$3.95
$23.95
Buy now
19 hrs
48 mins
Paw Paw 3 1/2” JOINTED PIKE Wood Lure In RAINBOW!!! Buy Now »

Paw Paw 3 1/2” JOINTED PIKE Wood Lure In RAINBOW!!!

Buy: $35.00 Ships:
$5.00
$40.00
Buy now
21 hrs
13 mins
MOONLIGHT??  3 3/4”  BASS ORENO Type Wood Lure In RAINBOW!!! Buy Now »

MOONLIGHT?? 3 3/4” BASS ORENO Type Wood Lure In RAINBOW!!!

Buy: $20.00 Ships:
$5.00
$25.00
Buy now
21 hrs
19 mins
PAW PAW BAIT Co Fishing Lure Small Jointed Pikie Vintage Wooden 3 1/2 inches Buy Now »

PAW PAW BAIT Co Fishing Lure Small Jointed Pikie Vintage Wooden 3 1/2 inches

Buy: $8.99 Ships:
Based on Zip
$8.99
Plus shipping
Buy now
21 hrs
19 mins
VINTAGE WOOD LURE MUSKIE Shur Strike Heddon Paw Paw HTF COLOR AND LURE Buy Now »

VINTAGE WOOD LURE MUSKIE Shur Strike Heddon Paw Paw HTF COLOR AND LURE

Buy: $39.99 Ships:
$4.50
$44.49
Buy now
21 hrs
44 mins
Vintage Paw Paw fishing lure, Hawaiian & other (lot#1391) Buy Now »

Vintage Paw Paw fishing lure, Hawaiian & other (lot#1391)

Buy: $16.95 Ships:
$3.50
$20.45
Buy now
23 hrs
51 mins
S8446 F VINTAGE paw paw wooden Fishing Lure Buy Now »

S8446 F VINTAGE paw paw wooden Fishing Lure

Buy: $10.50 Ships:
$3.50
$14.00
Buy now
23 hrs
51 mins
Vintage Lure Flying Ant Made in USA by Arnold Tackle Corp. Paw Paw, MI - NOS NM Buy Now »
Free Shipping

Vintage Lure Flying Ant Made in USA by Arnold Tackle Corp. Paw Paw, MI - NOS NM

Buy: $17.99 Ships:
Free
$17.99
Buy now
1 day
1 hr
36 mins
1941 PAW PAW GROOVE HEAD PIKIE WOOD 1.25" FLY ROD FISHING LURE-PIKE SCALE-NICE! Buy Now »

1941 PAW PAW GROOVE HEAD PIKIE WOOD 1.25" FLY ROD FISHING LURE-PIKE SCALE-NICE!

Buy: $8.00 Ships:
$3.50
$11.50
Buy now
1 day
7 hrs
11 mins
1940 PAW PAW JOINTED PIKIE WOOD 4.5" FISHING LURE-ARMY GREEN & WHITE SCALE!!! Buy Now »

1940 PAW PAW JOINTED PIKIE WOOD 4.5" FISHING LURE-ARMY GREEN & WHITE SCALE!!!

Buy: $10.00 Ships:
$3.50
$13.50
Buy now
1 day
7 hrs
11 mins
1936 PAW PAW BABY PIKIE WOOD 3.25" FISHING LURE-PIKE SCALE-TACK EYES-NICE!!! Buy Now »

1936 PAW PAW BABY PIKIE WOOD 3.25" FISHING LURE-PIKE SCALE-TACK EYES-NICE!!!

Buy: $12.00 Ships:
$3.50
$15.50
Buy now
1 day
7 hrs
11 mins
VINTAGE PAW PAW MIDGET SPINNING TORPEDO FISHING LURE Buy Now »

VINTAGE PAW PAW MIDGET SPINNING TORPEDO FISHING LURE

Buy: $20.00 Ships:
$3.50
$23.50
Buy now
1 day
7 hrs
18 mins
VINTAGE PAW PAW MIDGET SPINNER FISHING LURE blkfltr Buy Now »

VINTAGE PAW PAW MIDGET SPINNER FISHING LURE blkfltr

Buy: $14.00 Ships:
$3.90
$17.90
Buy now
1 day
7 hrs
22 mins
VINTAGE PAW PAW POPPER FISHING LURE gray Buy Now »

VINTAGE PAW PAW POPPER FISHING LURE gray

Buy: $25.00 Ships:
$3.50
$28.50
Buy now
1 day
7 hrs
25 mins
1940 PAW PAW PIKIE WOOD 4.25" FISHING LURE-SILVER FLASH-NICE!!! Buy Now »

1940 PAW PAW PIKIE WOOD 4.25" FISHING LURE-SILVER FLASH-NICE!!!

Buy: $15.00 Ships:
$3.50
$18.50
Buy now
1 day
7 hrs
50 mins
1941 PAW PAW PIKIE WOOD 4.25" FISHING LURE-RED HEAD & WHITE-NICE!!! Buy Now »

1941 PAW PAW PIKIE WOOD 4.25" FISHING LURE-RED HEAD & WHITE-NICE!!!

Buy: $12.00 Ships:
$3.50
$15.50
Buy now
1 day
7 hrs
50 mins
1940 PAW PAW PIKIE JOINTED WOOD 4.25" FISHING LURE-BLACK-NICE!!! Buy Now »

1940 PAW PAW PIKIE JOINTED WOOD 4.25" FISHING LURE-BLACK-NICE!!!

Buy: $15.00 Ships:
$3.50
$18.50
Buy now
1 day
7 hrs
50 mins
1925 MOONLIGHT BAIT CO. #3350 WOOD 3.75" FISHING LURE-RED HEAD & WHITE-NICE!!! Buy Now »

1925 MOONLIGHT BAIT CO. #3350 WOOD 3.75" FISHING LURE-RED HEAD & WHITE-NICE!!!

Buy: $50.00 Ships:
$3.50
$53.50
Buy now
1 day
7 hrs
50 mins
Vintage Fishing Lure Box, Paw Paw #3632 for Flap Jack, Clear Slide Top Buy Now »

Vintage Fishing Lure Box, Paw Paw #3632 for Flap Jack, Clear Slide Top

Buy: $9.99 Ships:
$3.50
$13.49
Buy now
1 day
12 hrs
34 mins
Paw Paw Nature Mouse - Grey Buy Now »

Paw Paw Nature Mouse - Grey

Buy: $24.99 Ships:
Based on Zip
$24.99
Plus shipping
Buy now
1 day
13 hrs
54 mins
PAW PAW 6100 Series WOODEN FISHING LURE 2-5/8" Size White Red Head Finish Buy Now »
Free Shipping

PAW PAW 6100 Series WOODEN FISHING LURE 2-5/8" Size White Red Head Finish

Buy: $19.99 Ships:
Free
$19.99
Buy now
1 day
14 hrs
17 mins
Vtg PAW PAW 812 River ROVER Go Getter WOODEN FISHING LURE Silver Flitter Flash Buy Now »
Free Shipping

Vtg PAW PAW 812 River ROVER Go Getter WOODEN FISHING LURE Silver Flitter Flash

Buy: $19.99 Ships:
Free
$19.99
Buy now
1 day
14 hrs
17 mins
PAW PAW Baby Jointed Pike WOODEN FISHING LURE Gold Scale Brown Back Buy Now »
Free Shipping

PAW PAW Baby Jointed Pike WOODEN FISHING LURE Gold Scale Brown Back

Buy: $22.50 Ships:
Free
$22.50
Buy now
1 day
14 hrs
20 mins
VINTAGE PAW PAW JUNIOR WOBBLER FISHING LURE terhwht Buy Now »

VINTAGE PAW PAW JUNIOR WOBBLER FISHING LURE terhwht

Buy: $15.00 Ships:
$3.90
$18.90
Buy now
1 day
16 hrs
43 mins
VINTAGE PAW PAW JUNIOR WOBBLER FISHING LURE tefrgspt Buy Now »

VINTAGE PAW PAW JUNIOR WOBBLER FISHING LURE tefrgspt

Buy: $14.00 Ships:
$3.90
$17.90
Buy now
1 day
16 hrs
45 mins
VINTAGE PAW PAW WOBBLER FISHING LURE tegrnscl Buy Now »

VINTAGE PAW PAW WOBBLER FISHING LURE tegrnscl

Buy: $9.00 Ships:
$3.90
$12.90
Buy now
1 day
16 hrs
49 mins
Vintage PAW PAW River Runt Style Wood Fishing Lure Buy Now »

Vintage PAW PAW River Runt Style Wood Fishing Lure

Buy: $24.99 Ships:
$3.50
$28.49
Buy now
1 day
17 hrs
4 mins
Paw Paw or Lucky Lures unknown? vintage fishing lure Bid Now » Buy Now »

Paw Paw or Lucky Lures unknown? vintage fishing lure

Bid: $14.99
Buy: $30.00
Ships:
$3.75
$18.74
Buy now
1 day
19 hrs
30 mins
S2340 VINTAGE PAW PAW RIVER RUNT FISHING LURE WOODEN ANTIQUE Buy Now »

S2340 VINTAGE PAW PAW RIVER RUNT FISHING LURE WOODEN ANTIQUE

Buy: $7.98 Ships:
$3.50
$11.48
Buy now
1 day
20 hrs
24 mins
 Paw Paw Flap Jack Flatfish Lure IN BOX Buy Now »

Paw Paw Flap Jack Flatfish Lure IN BOX

Buy: $20.00 Ships:
Free
$20.00
Buy now
2 days
7 hrs
33 mins
Vintage Paw Paw  Wounded Minnow Wood Fishing Lure Buy Now »

Vintage Paw Paw Wounded Minnow Wood Fishing Lure

Buy: $10.99 Ships:
$2.95
$13.94
Buy now
2 days
10 hrs
57 mins
PAW PAW JOINTED  WOOD LURE  02/27/17MW  Buy Now »

PAW PAW JOINTED WOOD LURE 02/27/17MW

Buy: $9.95 Ships:
$3.95
$13.90
Buy now
2 days
12 hrs
16 mins
Vintage Paw Paw River Go-Getter fishing lure Buy Now »
Free Shipping

Vintage Paw Paw River Go-Getter fishing lure

Buy: $24.99 Ships:
Free
$24.99
Buy now
2 days
17 hrs
28 mins


 Search eBay 
Search For In Category Min.
Price
Max.
Price
# Items
Per Page

 

You are here: Home » Moonlight & Paw Paw Lures