Moonlight & Paw Paw Fishing Lures

Vintage Moonlight Pikaroon, Pollywog, Little Wonder and other collectible lures from the Moonlight Bait Company and Paw Paw Bait Company for sale here.
Auctions Buy It Now All
Enter Zip or Post Code for shipping:
377 itemsPriceShippingTotalTime Left
1941 PAW PAW GROOVE HEAD PIKIE WOOD 1.25" FLY ROD FISHING LURE-PIKE SCALE-NICE! Buy Now »

1941 PAW PAW GROOVE HEAD PIKIE WOOD 1.25" FLY ROD FISHING LURE-PIKE SCALE-NICE!

Buy: $8.00 Ships:
$3.50
$11.50
Buy now
5 hrs
35 mins
1936 PAW PAW BABY PIKIE WOOD 3.25" FISHING LURE-PIKE SCALE-TACK EYES-NICE!!! Buy Now »

1936 PAW PAW BABY PIKIE WOOD 3.25" FISHING LURE-PIKE SCALE-TACK EYES-NICE!!!

Buy: $10.00 Ships:
$3.50
$13.50
Buy now
5 hrs
35 mins
1940 PAW PAW JOINTED PIKIE WOOD 4.5" FISHING LURE-ARMY GREEN & WHITE SCALE!!! Buy Now »

1940 PAW PAW JOINTED PIKIE WOOD 4.5" FISHING LURE-ARMY GREEN & WHITE SCALE!!!

Buy: $10.00 Ships:
$3.50
$13.50
Buy now
5 hrs
35 mins
1941 PAW PAW FLAPJACK 3.5" FISHING LURE-YELLOW SPOTTED-MICHIGAN BAIT!!! Buy Now »

1941 PAW PAW FLAPJACK 3.5" FISHING LURE-YELLOW SPOTTED-MICHIGAN BAIT!!!

Buy: $10.00 Ships:
$3.50
$13.50
Buy now
5 hrs
44 mins
1941 PAW PAW FLAPJACK 3.5" FISHING LURE-RARE STRAWBERRY SPOT-MICHIGAN BAIT-NICE! Buy Now »

1941 PAW PAW FLAPJACK 3.5" FISHING LURE-RARE STRAWBERRY SPOT-MICHIGAN BAIT-NICE!

Buy: $10.00 Ships:
$3.50
$13.50
Buy now
5 hrs
44 mins
1940 PAW PAW PIKIE JOINTED WOOD 4.25" FISHING LURE-BLACK-NICE!!! Buy Now »

1940 PAW PAW PIKIE JOINTED WOOD 4.25" FISHING LURE-BLACK-NICE!!!

Buy: $12.00 Ships:
$3.50
$15.50
Buy now
6 hrs
17 mins
1925 MOONLIGHT BAIT CO. #3350 WOOD 3.75" FISHING LURE-RED HEAD & WHITE-NICE!!! Buy Now »

1925 MOONLIGHT BAIT CO. #3350 WOOD 3.75" FISHING LURE-RED HEAD & WHITE-NICE!!!

Buy: $50.00 Ships:
$3.50
$53.50
Buy now
6 hrs
17 mins
Antique Climax Tackle Box w/Antique Lures Paw Paw Buy Now »

Antique Climax Tackle Box w/Antique Lures Paw Paw

Buy: $59.99 Ships:
$7.99
$67.98
Buy now
7 hrs
23 mins
Paw Paw Vintage Jointed Fishing Lure (B3L) Green Yellow Red Buy Now »
Free Shipping

Paw Paw Vintage Jointed Fishing Lure (B3L) Green Yellow Red

Buy: $29.95 Ships:
Free
$29.95
Buy now
8 hrs
7 mins
5 Pc Lot Old Vintage Wood Fishing Lure Heddon Basser Paw-Paw Pflueger Palomine  Bid Now » Buy Now »

5 Pc Lot Old Vintage Wood Fishing Lure Heddon Basser Paw-Paw Pflueger Palomine 

Bid: $18.00
Buy: $26.00
Ships:
Based on Zip
$18.00
Plus shipping
Buy now
9 hrs
21 mins
^^^Paw Paw Fishing Tackle Lures Michigan Bait Shop Man Cave Neon Wall Clock Sign Buy Now »

^^^Paw Paw Fishing Tackle Lures Michigan Bait Shop Man Cave Neon Wall Clock Sign

Buy: $77.99 Ships:
$22.00
$99.99
Buy now
10 hrs
32 mins
2 Nice Vintage Paw Paw Flapjack Lures Buy Now »
Free Shipping

2 Nice Vintage Paw Paw Flapjack Lures

Buy: $18.95 Ships:
Free
$18.95
Buy now
12 hrs
9 mins
Lot of Vintage Lures, Paw Paw P&K Dura Pak Etc. Plastic Buy Now »
Free Shipping

Lot of Vintage Lures, Paw Paw P&K Dura Pak Etc. Plastic

Buy: $24.95 Ships:
Free
$24.95
Buy now
12 hrs
33 mins
Paw Paw by Shakespeare wood fishing lure "Lucky Dog" Buy Now »

Paw Paw by Shakespeare wood fishing lure "Lucky Dog"

Buy: $13.99 Ships:
Based on Zip
$13.99
Plus shipping
Buy now
13 hrs
31 mins
Vintage Paw Paw Mouse Lure Bid Now » Buy Now »

Vintage Paw Paw Mouse Lure

Bid: $20.00
Buy: $30.00
Ships:
$5.00
$25.00
Buy now
16 hrs
6 mins
Vintage Moonlight Zig Zag 2.75" Lure 2T White/Red Top Water Buy Now »

Vintage Moonlight Zig Zag 2.75" Lure 2T White/Red Top Water

Buy: $69.99 Ships:
$3.99
$73.98
Buy now
17 hrs
3 mins
VINTAGE FISH LURE PAW PAW by Shakespeare DAPPER DAN MADE HONG KONG IN ORIG BOX Buy Now »
Free Shipping

VINTAGE FISH LURE PAW PAW by Shakespeare DAPPER DAN MADE HONG KONG IN ORIG BOX

Buy: $60.00 Ships:
Free
$60.00
Buy now
18 hrs
19 mins
Vintage Paw Paw fishing lure, Hawaiian & other (lot#1391) Buy Now »

Vintage Paw Paw fishing lure, Hawaiian & other (lot#1391)

Buy: $16.95 Ships:
$3.50
$20.45
Buy now
18 hrs
48 mins
Vintage Paw Paw Millsite Shakespeare Rainbow Fire  Runt Fishing Lure Tough color Buy Now »

Vintage Paw Paw Millsite Shakespeare Rainbow Fire  Runt Fishing Lure Tough color

Buy: $42.00 Ships:
$5.00
$47.00
Buy now
21 hrs
20 mins
VINTAGE PAW-PAW FLUTED LURE Buy Now »

VINTAGE PAW-PAW FLUTED LURE

Buy: $22.75 Ships:
$3.59
$26.34
Buy now
1 day
9 hrs
58 mins
VINTAGE PAW-PAW UNDERWATER MINNOW 1939 3300 SERIES Buy Now »

VINTAGE PAW-PAW UNDERWATER MINNOW 1939 3300 SERIES

Buy: $129.00 Ships:
$3.59
$132.59
Buy now
1 day
9 hrs
59 mins
Vintage 4-1/4” Wooden PAW-PAW Fluted Pikie Minnow Fishing Lure  Lot 8-266 Buy Now »

Vintage 4-1/4” Wooden PAW-PAW Fluted Pikie Minnow Fishing Lure Lot 8-266

Buy: $10.00 Ships:
$2.95
$12.95
Buy now
1 day
10 hrs
4 mins
2 Vintage Fishing Lures PAW PAW Darter 3-3/4” Body Fly rod Darter 1-1/2” Body Buy Now »

2 Vintage Fishing Lures PAW PAW Darter 3-3/4” Body Fly rod Darter 1-1/2” Body

Buy: $40.00 Ships:
$3.50
$43.50
Buy now
1 day
10 hrs
24 mins
OLD WOOD PAW PAW RIVER GO GETTER  RED/WHITE Metal Scoop FISHING LURE Bid Now » Buy Now »

OLD WOOD PAW PAW RIVER GO GETTER RED/WHITE Metal Scoop FISHING LURE

Bid: $9.99
Buy: $25.99
Ships:
$3.50
$13.49
Buy now
1 day
13 hrs
38 mins
RARE MOONLIGHT PIKAROON YELLOW FINISH Wood Fishing Lure Scarce TOUGH Buy Now »

RARE MOONLIGHT PIKAROON YELLOW FINISH Wood Fishing Lure Scarce TOUGH

Buy: $150.00 Ships:
$10.00
$160.00
Buy now
1 day
15 hrs
6 mins
Vintage Paw Paw  Aristocrat Torpedo 4" Lure White/Black  Top Water Buy Now »

Vintage Paw Paw Aristocrat Torpedo 4" Lure White/Black Top Water

Buy: $49.99 Ships:
$3.99
$53.98
Buy now
1 day
15 hrs
11 mins
Vintage PAW PAW River Runt Style Wood Fishing Lure Buy Now »

Vintage PAW PAW River Runt Style Wood Fishing Lure

Buy: $24.99 Ships:
$3.50
$28.49
Buy now
1 day
15 hrs
36 mins
Vintage Paw Paw Plunker Shad Pattern  3" Lure Top Water Buy Now »

Vintage Paw Paw Plunker Shad Pattern 3" Lure Top Water

Buy: $24.99 Ships:
$3.99
$28.98
Buy now
1 day
17 hrs
26 mins
VINTAGE PAW PAW BASS SEEKER FISHING LURE Buy Now »
Free Shipping

VINTAGE PAW PAW BASS SEEKER FISHING LURE

Buy: $19.95 Ships:
Free
$19.95
Buy now
1 day
18 hrs
3 mins
PAW PAW JIM DANDY BASS SEEKER OLD TIMER RED HEAD , GLITTER,  BEAUTIFUL , COLLECT Buy Now »

PAW PAW JIM DANDY BASS SEEKER OLD TIMER RED HEAD , GLITTER, BEAUTIFUL , COLLECT

Buy: $34.99 Ships:
$4.00
$38.99
Buy now
1 day
18 hrs
19 mins
Antique Very Nice Cork Body Weedless Bass Lure Popper Paw Paw Chippewa Dickens ? Buy Now »

Antique Very Nice Cork Body Weedless Bass Lure Popper Paw Paw Chippewa Dickens ?

Buy: $32.95 Ships:
Based on Zip
$32.95
Plus shipping
Buy now
1 day
20 hrs
20 mins
Vtg Moonlight Bait Co. Moonlight No. 1 Fishing Lure Original Box and Paperwork Buy Now »

Vtg Moonlight Bait Co. Moonlight No. 1 Fishing Lure Original Box and Paperwork

Buy: $18.00 Ships:
$3.00
$21.00
Buy now
1 day
22 hrs
38 mins
Paw Paw Bait Co. Fishing Lures Rustic Retro Metal Sign 8" x 12" Buy Now »
Free Shipping

Paw Paw Bait Co. Fishing Lures Rustic Retro Metal Sign 8" x 12"

Buy: $23.99 Ships:
Free
$23.99
Buy now
2 days
8 hrs
6 mins
Paw Paw “WOTTA FROG” Wood Lure Yellow Buy Now »

Paw Paw “WOTTA FROG” Wood Lure Yellow

Buy: $85.00 Ships:
$3.85
$88.85
Buy now
2 days
9 hrs
4 mins
Vintage Moonlight Brilliant Bass Seeker, 4" Long Lure With GE's, Very Nice Bait! Buy Now »

Vintage Moonlight Brilliant Bass Seeker, 4" Long Lure With GE's, Very Nice Bait!

Buy: $84.95 Ships:
Free
$84.95
Buy now
2 days
12 hrs
57 mins
4 Vintage Creek Chub Paw Paw etc Pikie Type and others Lures Various Colors Buy Now »

4 Vintage Creek Chub Paw Paw etc Pikie Type and others Lures Various Colors

Buy: $49.95 Ships:
$7.95
$57.90
Buy now
2 days
13 hrs
2 mins
Vintage 3-1/4” Wooden Unmarked (PAW-PAW?) Fishing Lure  Lot 8-302 Buy Now »

Vintage 3-1/4” Wooden Unmarked (PAW-PAW?) Fishing Lure Lot 8-302

Buy: $8.00 Ships:
$2.95
$10.95
Buy now
2 days
13 hrs
14 mins
5 Vintage Wood Fishing Lures Paw Paw Shoffner and Others Various Colors Buy Now »

5 Vintage Wood Fishing Lures Paw Paw Shoffner and Others Various Colors

Buy: $49.95 Ships:
$7.95
$57.90
Buy now
2 days
13 hrs
15 mins
6 Beautiful Vintage Pikie Type Creek Chub Golden Shiner Paw Paw Fishing Lures Buy Now »

6 Beautiful Vintage Pikie Type Creek Chub Golden Shiner Paw Paw Fishing Lures

Buy: $39.95 Ships:
$7.95
$47.90
Buy now
2 days
13 hrs
44 mins
Tough Vintage MOONLIGHT Minnow Spinner Lure 3000 Series Rare Fishing Bait Nice Buy Now »

Tough Vintage MOONLIGHT Minnow Spinner Lure 3000 Series Rare Fishing Bait Nice

Buy: $215.00 Ships:
$5.00
$220.00
Buy now
2 days
15 hrs
14 mins
VINTAGE EARLY RARE MOONLIGHT Silver Creek JOINTED PIKAROON no eyes Fishing Lure Buy Now »

VINTAGE EARLY RARE MOONLIGHT Silver Creek JOINTED PIKAROON no eyes Fishing Lure

Buy: $150.00 Ships:
$5.65
$155.65
Buy now
2 days
15 hrs
21 mins
VINTAGE PAW PAW RIVER GO-GETTER FISHING LURE GREEN GOLD DOT COLOR scarce bait Buy Now »

VINTAGE PAW PAW RIVER GO-GETTER FISHING LURE GREEN GOLD DOT COLOR scarce bait

Buy: $37.95 Ships:
Based on Zip
$37.95
Plus shipping
Buy now
2 days
15 hrs
21 mins
Vintage Paw Paw Fishing LURE NICE River Master Type Fishing Bait TOUGH COLOR WOW Buy Now »

Vintage Paw Paw Fishing LURE NICE River Master Type Fishing Bait TOUGH COLOR WOW

Buy: $65.00 Ships:
$5.00
$70.00
Buy now
2 days
15 hrs
21 mins
Vintage Paw Paw Wobbler Junior Old Faithful Lure EARLY PAINTED CUP Hardware wood Buy Now »

Vintage Paw Paw Wobbler Junior Old Faithful Lure EARLY PAINTED CUP Hardware wood

Buy: $25.00 Ships:
$5.00
$30.00
Buy now
2 days
15 hrs
21 mins
Vintage Paw Paw River Go Getter Lure Wood Unique Orange Glass Eyes Unmarked Lip Buy Now »

Vintage Paw Paw River Go Getter Lure Wood Unique Orange Glass Eyes Unmarked Lip

Buy: $35.00 Ships:
$5.00
$40.00
Buy now
2 days
15 hrs
21 mins
Vintage RARE Fishing Lure Moonlight Comstock Chunk in Black Tough Color Wood HTF Buy Now »

Vintage RARE Fishing Lure Moonlight Comstock Chunk in Black Tough Color Wood HTF

Buy: $75.00 Ships:
$5.00
$80.00
Buy now
2 days
15 hrs
21 mins
Vintage Fishing Lure Wood Paw Paw River Runt Wooden 3" Tough Color Glass Eyes Buy Now »

Vintage Fishing Lure Wood Paw Paw River Runt Wooden 3" Tough Color Glass Eyes

Buy: $47.95 Ships:
$5.00
$52.95
Buy now
2 days
15 hrs
21 mins
Paw Paw Jointed fishing lure (lot#12406) Buy Now »

Paw Paw Jointed fishing lure (lot#12406)

Buy: $17.95 Ships:
$3.50
$21.45
Buy now
2 days
18 hrs
23 mins
Vintage fishing lure Unknown maker Paw Paw or Lucky Strike ? (Lot#12416) Buy Now »

Vintage fishing lure Unknown maker Paw Paw or Lucky Strike ? (Lot#12416)

Buy: $25.00 Ships:
$6.50
$31.50
Buy now
2 days
18 hrs
38 mins
VINTAGE 6 1/2" CREEK CHUB, HEDDON, SOUTH BEND,PAW PAW, PFLUGER JOINTED MINNOW? Buy Now »

VINTAGE 6 1/2" CREEK CHUB, HEDDON, SOUTH BEND,PAW PAW, PFLUGER JOINTED MINNOW?

Buy: $14.99 Ships:
Based on Zip
$14.99
Plus shipping
Buy now
3 days
10 hrs
12 mins


 Search eBay 
Search For In Category Min.
Price
Max.
Price
# Items
Per Page

 

You are here: Home » Moonlight & Paw Paw Lures